Figures
Abstract
Rehmannia is a medicinal plant in China. Autotoxicity has been reported to be one of the major problems hindering the consecutive monoculture of Rehmannia. However, potential autotoxins produced by the fibrous roots are less known. In this study, the autotoxicity of these fibrous roots was investigated. Four groups of autotoxic compounds from the aqueous extracts of the fibrous roots were isolated and characterized. The ethyl acetate extracts of these water-soluble compounds were further analyzed and separated into five fractions. Among them, the most autotoxic fraction (Fr 3) was subjected to GC/MS analysis, resulting in 32 identified compounds. Based on literature, nine compounds were selected for testing their autotoxic effects on radicle growth. Seven out of the nine compounds were phenolic, which significantly reduced radicle growth in a concentration-dependent manner. The other two were aliphatic compounds that showed a moderate inhibition effect at three concentrations. Concentration of these compounds in soil samples was determined by HPLC. Furthermore, the autotoxic compounds were also found in the top soil of the commercially cultivated Rehmannia fields. It appears that a close link exists between the autotoxic effects on the seedlings and the compounds extracted from fibrous roots of Rehmannia.
Citation: Li Z-F, Yang Y-Q, Xie D-F, Zhu L-F, Zhang Z-G, Lin W-X (2012) Identification of Autotoxic Compounds in Fibrous Roots of Rehmannia (Rehmannia glutinosa Libosch.). PLoS ONE 7(1): e28806. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0028806
Editor: Alejandra Bravo, Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico,Instituto de Biotecnologia, Mexico
Received: July 24, 2011; Accepted: November 15, 2011; Published: January 3, 2012
Copyright: © 2012 Li et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work was supported by The National Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 30772729), Provincial Natural Science Foundation of Fujian, China (No. 2008J0051), and the key discipline program of Fujian Province, China (grant No. 20020F012). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Introduction
Rehmannia (Rehmannia glutinosa Libosch) is in the Scrophulariaceae family and is one of the most common and important medicinal herbal plants in China. It is perennial and its fresh or dried tuberous roots are used as a high demand traditional Chinese medicinal ingredient for hematologic conditions, sedation, insomnia and diabetes [1], [2]. Its commercial cultivation has been practiced for almost 1500 years in China. However, the consecutively monocultured plants are prone to severe diseases resulting in reduced biomass, especially the tuberous products. To maintain the cultivation, the farmers commonly limited the cultivation on a same plot once every eight years. Therefore, less desirable areas outside Jiaozuo had to be used for the planting with decreased tuber yields and lower product quality [3].
The autotoxicity issue has attracted much attention [4], [5]. Autotoxicity is the phenomenon whereby mature plants inhibit the growth of their own seedlings through the release of autotoxic chemicals. It has been found to exist in various crops [6], [7], such as greenhouse crops [8], [9], fruits [10], [11], forage [12], [13], horticultural and medicinal plants [4], [5], [14], [15], [16]. Several groups of chemicals have been implicated in autotoxicity, including terpenoids, phenolics, steroids, alkaloids, and cyanogenic glycosides. Recently, autotoxicity in Rehmannia has been reported [15],[16],[17] especially in relation to the compounds derived from the root exudates. However, to date, the degradation of fibrous roots and its products had not been studied, and the mechanism of autotoxicity in Rehmannia remains unknown.
This study aims to identify substances that contribute directly to Rehmannia autotoxicity. A number of potentially autotoxic compounds from the fibrous roots were isolated and characterized. The inhibitory effect of these compounds on seedling growth was observed. Furthermore, the concentration of these bioactive compounds in the top soil collected from one-year cultivated and two-year consecutively moncultured Rehmannia fields was determined.
Materials and Methods
Sample collection and autotoxic compound extraction
Water extraction.
The fields were located in Jiao-zuo County (113°21′E, 35°24′N), He-nan province of China, which is the optimal production areas of Rehmannia. The samples were collected in October 2008 (Figure S1).
Fibrous roots of one-year cultivated Rehmannia plants at the mature stage were collected. The air-dried roots (500 g), passed 2 mm sieve, were soaked in 1000 mL distilled water at 25–30°C for 48 h. The extract was filtered, and the extraction was repeated three times. The aqueous extracts from the three extractions were combined and concentrated to 20 mL under vacuum at 50°C, then freeze-dried under liquid N2 at −180°C Approximately 530 mg of the dried material were obtained from the 500 g of air-dried fibrous roots.
Top soil samples (20 cm depth) were collected from both one-year cultivated and two-year consecutively moncultured Rehmannia fields in Jiaozuo county at harvest time. A soil sample from an adjacent uncultivated field was collected as a control. Potential autotoxic compounds were extracted from the soil samples using the same method for the fibrous roots. Approximately 400 mg of dried material were obtained from the 500 g air-dried soil samples.
Ethanol extraction and partitioning.
Air-dried fibrous roots (2 kg) were extracted with 95% ethanol (5 L) at room temperature for 5 d. This process was repeated once. The extract was concentrated by evaporation to 200 mL at 50°C under vacuum followed by freeze-drying under liquid N2 (−180°C), and then dissolved in 200 mL distilled water.
The aqueous solution was consecutively partitioned with petroleum ether, chloroform, ethyl acetate, and n-butanol, as shown in Figure 1. The solvent extractions were performed by shaking in separation funnels for 10 min, followed by evaporation under vacuum.
Bioassays and statistical analysis
To examine the functional effect of the potential autotoxic compounds on Rehmannia growth, measurements of Rehmannia radicles in petri dishes was performed. The extracts of petroleum ether, chloroform, ethyl acetate, n-butanol and the ethyl acetate-extracted fractions (1–5), of fibrous roots, monocultured soils for 1 year and 2 years, and uncultivated soil, were diluted with distilled water into 2, 5, 10, 20 and 50 mg L−1. 5 mL of each of the diluted solutions were transferred into the 10-cm diameter petri dishes containing double-layered filter paper (Whatman No. 42). In addition, individual compounds, including 7 aliphatic and 2 phenolics as identified in Fr3, were dissolved in a small volume of methanol and transferred onto the double-layered filter paper in the petri dishes. The solvents were evaporated in a draft chamber for 1 h. The filter paper containing these compounds was moistened with 5 mL distilled water. The final concentrations of the compounds in water were 2, 10, and 50 mg L−1, while distilled water was used as control. Twenty Rehmannia seeds were placed on the filter paper in the petri dishes. All dishes were maintained in a tissue culture room at 26°C with fluorescent lights for 11 h (8∶00–20∶00) as described previously [7]. The fluorescent light intensity was 4.17±0.18×103 lux. Germinated seeds with >1 mm radius were recorded and the radicle lengths were measured after incubation for 5 d.
The radicle lengths of the treated ones in comparison with the controls were used as an index of the inhibition rates (IRs). IR was calculated as: IR = (control - treatment)/control×100%. When IR is greater than 0, it indicates an inhibition; conversely when IR is less than 0, it indicates promoting growth [18]. All data were subject to an analysis of variance using the Statistical Analysis System Program (SPSS). Each value was expressed as the mean of three replicates±standard error (SE).
Identification of autotoxic chemicals
The ethyl acetate extract was further analyzed. About 8 g of the extract was subjected to column chromatography (CC), packed with silica gel (200–300 mesh) and eluted with chloroform (CHCl3)-methanol (MeOH), followed by a gradient solvent system (0–100 MeOH) to yield five fractions (Fr1-5). The fractions were analyzed by thin-layer chromatography (TLC) on the same Rf value. Preliminary bioassay study indicated that fraction 3 (Fr3) exhibited the greatest inhibitory activity on radicle growth of Rehmannia. Thus, Fr3 was further purified using the reversed phase multi-purpose GC column chromatography (Varian, California, U.S.A., VF-5 ms, 30 m×0.25 mm×0.25 µm).
The GC/MS fingerprints of Fr3 were obtained with a GC/MS (Autospec-240 MS Ion Trap mass spectroscopy, Varian, California, U.S.A.). Fraction 3 was subsequently dissolved into 2 mL redistilled MeOH. One µL aliquot of this solution was evaporated under a stream of helium to remove residual water. A mixture of 10 µL redistilled MeOH and 10 µL N, O-Bis (trimethylsilyl) trifluoro acetamide (BSTFA) + 1% trimethylchlorosilane (TMCS) was added to the residue to produce trimethylsilyl derivatives by heating at 100°C for 1 h. The solution was filtered through a 0.45 µm filter before injected into the GC-MS system.
The injection volume was 1 µL. Helium was used as the carrier gas, and the flow rate was adjusted to 10 mL min−1. The oven temperature was initially programmed at 50°C and ramped to 270°C at a rate of 5°C·min−1, where it remained for 10 min. MS data were acquired in the negative ionization mode. The full scan mass covered a range from m/z 50 to 1500. The m/z values for standard autotoxins and the compounds as available in the literature were used to match with those obtained in the spectra for the study.
HPLC analysis
To determine whether the autotoxic compounds identified in Rehmannia root extracts also existed in ground soil, we tested the soil samples.
The concentration of autotoxic compounds in soil samples was determined using a Waters HPLC system (Alliance HPLC system Massachusetts, U.S.A.).The chromatographic system consisting of a Waters 2695 HPLC system with a reversed-phase column Zorbax Eclipse XDB –C18 (250 mm×4.6 mm, 5 µm column) was used at a flow rate of 1.0 mL min−1. The solvent system was a linear gradient of solvent A (methanol) and solvent B (0.5 mol L−1 acetic acid in water): from 1% to 25% A in 0–10.0 min, and hold at 25% A for 5 min;from 25% to 80% A in 15.0–25.0 min, and hold at 80% A for 5 min;from 80% to 25% A in 30.0–40.0 min, and hold at 25% A for 10 min. The injected volume was 10 mL of a water solution of the extracts (10 mg mL−1). The column temperature was maintained at 35°C. The UV detector was performed at 280 nm. The chromatographic data were recorded and processed with a Waters empower workstation.
HPLC grade acetonitrile, acetic acid (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany), and filtered bi-distilled water, were used for HPLC analysis. The methanol used for extraction was from “Honeywell International” (New Jersey, U.S.A.). Standards of phenolic acids, including (gallic acid, 4-hydroxybenzoic acid, vanillic acid, protocatechuic acid, ferulic acid, benzoic acid, and salicylic acid,) were purchased from Sigma Chemicals Co., U.S.A.. Solvents and standards of phenolic acids were chromatographic grade. The specific recovery rates (%) for the standards were: gallic acid, 96.24±4.42;4-Hydroxybenzoic acid, 92.26±5.35; vanillic acid, 92.15±3.22; protocatechuic acid, 92.44±5.06; ferulic acid, 93.25±5.31; benzoic acid, 90.01±4.38; and salicylic acid, 90.06±3.21.
The dry materials from the water extract were dissolved into 100 mL methanol and passed through a 0.22 µm glass fiber sieve. 7 Phenolic acids compounds found in the samples extracts were dentified by matching the retention time and their spectral characteristics against those of standards. The separation procedures were repeated six times for each standard compound, and data were presented as mean±SE.
Results
Bioassay of fibrous root extracts
When compared with the root exudates and the extracts of three different soils (i.e. control soil, one-year monocultured and two-year monocultured soils), the autotoxic compounds extracted from the fibrous roots showed greater inhibitive effects on the radicle growth of Rehmannia (Table 1). The inhibition rate increased with higher concentrations of the extracts. The IR peaked at 50 mg·L−1 with 75.76% reduction in seedling radicles (P<0.01; Table 1). A similar trend was found in the soil extracts, but their inhibitory effects were always lower than those of the fibrous roots'. The result indicated that the chemical compounds extracted from the fibrous roots had a major auto-inhibitory effect on the growth of Rehmannia radicle.
Bioassay of partitioned compounds of fibrous root extracts
The bioassay with petroleum ether, chloroform, ethyl acetate, and n-butanol partitions showed that the four extracts exhibited dose-dependent inhibition effects on the radicle growth and that the ethyl acetate extract had the greatest inhibitory effect (Table 2). At the concentration of 50 mg L−1, the inhibition rates of petroleum ether, chloroform, ethyl acetate, and n-butanol extracts were 8.7%, 5.8%, 64.2%, and 25.8%, respectively.
Bioassay of column chromatography fractions of ethyl acetate extract
Bioassays with each of the five fractions from ethyl acetate extract showed a significant reduction in the length of the radicle in the presence of Fr3 (P<0.01; Table 3). When the concentration was greater than 20 mg L−1, the reduction reached 100%. This indicates that the chemical compounds in Fr3 had a major auto-inhibitory effect on the seedling growth, and so Fr3 was considered a candidate for further identification and characterization.
Autotoxic effect of compounds identified in fraction 3
By comparing with a GC/MS user-library spectrum of pure reference compounds, GC/MS analysis for Fr3 identified a total of 32 compounds in Fr3. They were classified into 5 groups: phenolics, aliphatic compounds, terpenoids, steroids, and others (Figure 2, Table 4).
Previous studies suggested that several chemicals detected in the bioactive Fr3 were possibly allelopathic compounds, which were reported as allelochemicals in other crops [4],[8],[19]. Based on previous reports and the availability of the chemicals in Fr3, nine individual compounds were selected to test their potential autotoxic effects on Rehmannia radicle growth (Table 5). Among the 9 chemicals examined, seven phenolic compounds showed dose-respondent inhibitory effects on the seedling growth. Specifically, the radicle of the seedlings reduced significantly by 45–76% when they were treated with the phenolic compounds (except salicylic acid) at a concentration of 50 mg·L−1 (P<0.01). Ferulic acid and vanillin acid were the most potent compounds in the test, and therefore, they were considered as the potential allelochemicals. All of the compounds inhibited the seedling growth even at a low concentration (e.g., 2 mg·L−1, P<0.01), and IRs increased with increasing concentrations. Similarly, the compounds in the aliphatic acid family (e.g., tetradecanoic acid and oleic acid) exhibited dose-respondent inhibitory effects on the seedling growth. The extent of inhibition was around 25% for each compound (Table 5). The results demonstrate clearly that the compounds extracted from the roots of Rehmannia are potent inhibitors on seedling growth. In addition, both the phenolic acid and aliphatic acid compounds might contribute to the autotoxicity of Rehmannia.
Identification of autotoxic compounds in soil samples
In the fields where Rehmannia were monocultivated for 1 year and 2 years, seven phenolic compounds identified as the potential autotoxins were found at different concentrations (Table 6, Figure 3), 4-hydroxybenzoic acid being the most abundant. In the control and 1-year monocultured soil samples, only 6 phenolic compounds were detected. Thus, the findings presented here indicate that the compounds identified in Rehmannia roots can be found in relative abundance in soils previously cultivated with Rehmannia, whereas they are absent or present at much lower concentrations in non-cultivated soils. Furthermore, the higher inhibitory chemical concentration in the consecutively monocultured soil than in the newly planted soil was due to the accumulation of autotoxic compounds in the rhizosphere soil.
Compounds detected from samples in order of appearance in eluant: gallic acid (1), protocatechuic acid (2), 4-hydroxybenzoic acid (3), vanillic acid (4), salicylic acid (5), ferulic acid (6), and benzoic acid (7).
Discussion
Our results demonstrate that the compounds isolated from ethyl acetate-soluble extracts of Rehmannia fibrous roots had the most auto-inhibitory effects on the seedling growth. Specifically, 32 chemicals were identified by GC/MS that included 9 aliphatic, 10 phenolic, 4 terpene, 4 steroids and 5 other compounds. Among them, the 7 phenolic compounds and 2 aliphatic acids selected for testing the inhibition effects showed a significant suppressive function on the seedling growth. The inhibitory effects were somewhat related to the concentration of the autotoxins. More importantly, all 7 bioactive phenolic compounds were detected in the top soil of the Rehmannia fields. It appeared that our study provided the first direct evidence that the autotoxic chemicals detected in the soils of different-year consecutively monocultured Rehmannia fields could be traced back to the roots of Rehmannia. During soil sample collection, we noticed that a large amount of fibrous root waste was left in the soil after harvest. It is likely that the autotoxic compounds found in soils were derived partly from the root exudates or the degraded plant tissues. Once released into the soil and allowed to accumulate, these compounds might play a major role in the autotoxic effects on the seedling growth.
In this study, we found that the inhibitory effect of each single compound was not as potent as the bioactive Fr3 (which contained all compounds). It might result from the additive or synergistic effect of the mixture compounds extracted from Rehmannia fibrous roots and its rhizosphere soil. The similar results were reported in the case of other plants [20],[21].
The consecutive monoculture problems in the case study were also defined as “replanting disease” or “sick soil syndrome”, and it is a very common phenomenon in many fruit trees, such as apples, pears, and plums. A wide variety of tree pathogens, including bacteria, fungi, nematodes, and viruses, have been linked to the “replanting disease” in fruit trees. These pathogens may not be harmful to the mature trees, yet they retard the growth of young trees in the same field [22]. It has been reported that the presence of fungal pathogens in soils contributes to the “replanting disease” of Rehmannia [23],[24]. However, this study provides evidence that the autotoxicity is another major cause of the disease [4]. Identification of the autotoxic compounds in this study might be helpful to further understand the problems associated with consecutive monoculture of Rehmannia, and it was also conducive to make the solution to effectively control the “replanting disease” for Rehmannia in consecutively cropping sequence.
Author Contributions
Conceived and designed the experiments: Z-FL W-XL. Performed the experiments: Z-FL Y-QY D-FX L-FZ Z-GZ. Analyzed the data: Z-FL Y-QY D-FX L-FZ Z-GZ W-XL. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: W-XL. Wrote the paper: Z-FL.
References
- 1. Cui YY, Hahn EJ, Kozai T, Paek KY (2000) Number of air exchanges, sucrose concentration, photosynthetic photon flux, and differences in photoperiod and dark period temperatures affect growth of Rehmannia glutinosa plantlets in vitro. Plant Cell Tiss Org 62: 219–226.
- 2. Zhao HJ, Tan JF, Qi CM (2007) Photosynthesis of Rehmannia glutinosa subjected to drought stress is enhanced by choline chloride through alleviating lipid peroxidation and increasing proline accumulation. Plant Growth Regul 51: 255–262.
- 3. Zhang Z, Lei CY, Zhang LF, Yang XX, Chen R, et al. (2008) The complete nucleotide sequence of a novel Tobamovirus, Rehmannia mosaic virus. Arch Virol 153: 595–599.
- 4. Zhao YJ, Wang YP, Shao D, Yang JS, Liu DS (2005) Autotoxicity of Panax quinquefolium L. Allelopathy J 15: 67–74.
- 5. Hao ZP, Wang Q, Christie P, Li XL (2007) Allelopathic potential of watermelon tissues and root exudates. Sci Hortic-Amsterdam 112: 315–320.
- 6. Chou CH, Lin HJ (1976) Autointoxication mechanisms of Oryza sativa. J Chem Ecol 2: 353–367.
- 7. Wu HW, Pratley J, Lemerle D, An M, Liu DL (2007) Autotoxicity of wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) as determined by laboratory bioassays. Plant Soil l296: 85–93.
- 8. Yu JQ, Shou SY, Qian YR, Zhu ZJ, Hu WH (2000) Autotoxic potential of cucurbit crops. Plant Soil 223: 147–151.
- 9. Chon SU, Boo HO (2005) Difference in allelopathic potential as influenced by root periderm colour of sweet potato (Ipomoea batatas). J Agron Crop Sci 191: 75–80.
- 10. Manici LM, Ciavatta C, Kelderer M, Erschbaumer G (2003) Replant problems in South Tyrol: role of fungal pathogens and microbial population in conventional and organic apple orchards. Plant Soil 256: 315–324.
- 11. Wilson S, Andrews P, Nair TS (2004) Non-fumigant management of apple replant disease. Sci Hortic-amsterdam 102: 221–231.
- 12. Chon SU, Nelson CJ, Coutts JH (2004) Osmotic and Autotoxic Effects of Leaf Extracts on Germination and Seedling Growth of Alfalfa. Agron J 96: 1673–1679.
- 13. Canals RM, Emeterio LS, Peralta J (2005) Autotoxicity in Lolium rigidum: analyzing the role of chemically mediated interactions in annual plant populations. J Theor Biol 235: 402–407.
- 14. Bogatek R, Gniazdowska A, Zakrzewska W, Oracz K, Gawronski SW (2006) Allelopathic effects of sunflower extracts on mustard seed germination and seedling growth. Biol Plantarum 50: 156–158.
- 15. Gao WW, Zhao YJ, Wang YP, Chen SL (2006) A review of research on sustainable use of medicinal plants cropland in China (in Chinese). China Journal of Chinese Materia Medica 31: 1665–1668.
- 16. Du JF, Yin WJ, Zhang ZY, Hou J, Huang J, et al. (2009) Autotoxicity and Phenolic Acids Content in Soils with Different Planting Interval Years of Rehmannia glutinosa (in Chinese). Chinese Journal of Ecology 48: 445–450.
- 17. Liu HY, Wang F, Wang YP, Lu CT (2006) The Causes and Control of Continuous Cropping Barrier in Dihuang (in Chinese). Journal of North China Agriculture 21: 131–132.
- 18. Lin WX, Kim KU, Shin DH (2000) Allelopathic potential in rice (Oryza sativa L.) and its modes of action on Barnyardgrass (Echinochloa crusgalli L.). Allelopathy J 7: 215–224.
- 19. Kalinova J, Vrchotova N, Triska J (2007) Exudation of allelopathic substances in buckwheat (Fagopyrum esculentum Moench). J Agr Food Chem 55: 6453–6459.
- 20. Einhellig FA (1996) Interactions involving allelopathy in cropping systems. Agron J 88: 886–893.
- 21. Kong C, Hu F, Xu T, Lu Y (1999) Allelopathic potential and chemical constituents of volatile oil from ageratum conyzoides. J Chem Ecol 25: 2347–2356.
- 22. Weller DM, Raaijmakers JM, Gardener BM, Thomashow LS (2002) Microbial populations responsible for specific soil suppressiveness to plant pathogens. Annu Rev Phytopathol 40: 309–348.
- 23. Xie HE, Wang JJ, Xie XH, Li JH, Chen L, et al. (2007) Identification and Morbidityu Test of Pathogenic Fungi in the Soil Samples Planted Rehmnnia gintinosa. Journal of Shanxi Agriculture Science 35: 59–63.
- 24. Li J, Wang M, Lin ZP, Yuan QJ, Yu RM, et al. (2010) Isolation and identification of endophytic fungi from different swollenroot of Rehmannia glutinosa. China Journal of Chinese Materia Medica 35: 1679–1683.