Figures
Abstract
The javascript:void(0)manipulation and sustained effects of acupuncture have been investigated in multiple studies, but several findings are inconsistent with one another. One possible explanation for these discrepancies is that different modalities of acupuncture were utilized in these studies. In the present study, we investigated both the manipulation and sustained effects of acupuncture in different modalities, including manual acupuncture (MA), electroacupuncture (EA) and transcutaneous electrical acupoint stimulation (TEAS). MA, EA, TEAS and sensory control stimulation were applied to 18 healthy subjects, and combined block-designed and resting-state fMRI scans were performed. In analyzing these data, the block-designed datasets were used to assess the manipulation effect by employing a modified general linear model. The data from the resting states, before and after stimulation, were used to explore the brain networks involved in the sustained effect. The results showed that the two 1-min stimulation periods produced similar activation patterns in the sensory control with positive activation in the sensorimotor areas and negative activation in the default mode areas. Although similar patterns could be detected in the first stimulation period in MA, EA and TEAS, no positive activation result was observed in the second stimulation period, and EA showed a more extensive deactivation compared to MA and TEAS. Additionally, all three of the modalities of acupuncture stimulation could increase the instinct brain network in rest. A more secure and spatially extended connectivity of the default mode network was observed following MA and EA, and TEAS specifically increased the functional connectivity in the sensorimotor network. The present study suggested that different brain mechanisms might be recruited in different acupuncture modalities. In addition, the findings from our work could provide methodological information for further research into the mechanism of acupuncture.
Citation: Jiang Y, Wang H, Liu Z, Dong Y, Dong Y, Xiang X, et al. (2013) Manipulation of and Sustained Effects on the Human Brain Induced by Different Modalities of Acupuncture: An fMRI Study. PLoS ONE 8(6): e66815. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0066815
Editor: Wang Zhan, University of Maryland, College Park, United States of America
Received: February 9, 2013; Accepted: May 9, 2013; Published: June 28, 2013
Copyright: © 2013 Jiang et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work was supported by the National Basic Research Program of China (2007CB512501, 2013CB531905, 2009CB522003). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. No additional external funding was received for this study.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Introduction
Acupuncture is a traditional Chinese treatment that has been used in the Orient for thousands of years and is now gaining widespread acceptance as an alternative and complementary treatment in modern medicine [1]. In addition to traditional manual acupuncture (MA), new acupuncture modalities, such as electroacupuncture (EA) and transcutaneous electrical acupoint stimulation (TEAS), are gaining in popularity.
Unlike MA, which uses manual needling at specific acupoints to achieve a therapeutic effect, in EA, electrical pulses are delivered on the needles inserted into the acupoints, and in TEAS, electrical pulses are delivered on the skin of the acupoints via electrode. There is solid evidence that both EA and TEAS have treatment effects on pain [2], [3] and substance abuse [4], [5] in both humans and animal models. In addition, Zhang et al. recently reported that TEAS could increase the success rate for women undergoing embryo transfer [6] and also had the potential to improve autistic behavior in children [7]. Compared to MA, EA is more effective in pain relief [8], [9], and the precision of the simulation parameters ensures high reproducibility for therapeutic effects and research. Additionally, EA without manual manipulation of the needles also saves labor. TEAS has been shown to be as effective as EA in analgesia [10], and with training for nurses and patients, it can be performed even without an acupuncturist. Furthermore, the non-invasiveness of the procedure makes it more acceptable to patients.
Previous studies in animals have shown that acupuncture stimulation could facilitate the release of specific neuropeptides in the central nervous system and elicit profound physiological effects [11]. However, the exploration of acupuncture mechanisms in the human brain was limited by lack of noninvasive methods until the recent development of imaging techniques, particularly functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI). Research has mainly focused on two acupuncture effects: the manipulation and sustained effects. A block-designed method has mostly been used for detecting the manipulation effect of acupuncture, and it has generally been accepted that acupuncture deactivates the limbic system and activates sensorimotor areas [12], [13], [14], [15], [16], [17]. Resting-state connectivity has mostly been used to investigate the sustained effect of acupuncture, and increased functional connectivity in the resting brain network following acupuncture has been observed in many studies [18], [19], [20], [21], [22]. However, only one modality of acupuncture was utilized in these works, and varied results were often reported [23]. It is reasonable to wonder whether different modalities of acupuncture could induce different brain activity responses. To the best of our knowledge, only a small number of studies attempted to compare the manipulation effect induced by MA and EA [24], [25], [26], and the brain activation patterns observed in these studies seemed inconsistent. We hypothesize that these discrepancies may be due to small sample sizes and less powerful statistical thresholds.
The aim of the present study is to investigate both the manipulation and sustained effects induced by three popularly utilized acupuncture modalities, namely, MA, EA and TEAS. We used block-designed datasets combined with a modified general linear model (GLM) analysis [27] to observe the manipulation effect. Data from the resting states before and after stimulation were also collected to detect the sustained effect of acupuncture. On the basis of former studies, the default mode network (DMN) and the sensorimotor network (SMN) could be modulated by acupuncture [18], [21], [28]; thus, our exploration of the sustained effect focused on these two networks.
Materials and Methods
Subjects
Eighteen healthy, right-handed participants naïve to acupuncture (9 male, mean age-22 years, range-19 to 27) were enrolled in this experiment. Prior to the commencement of the experiment, all subjects signed an informed consent agreement regarding the purpose, procedure and potential risks of this study and were free to withdraw from the experiment at any time. All research procedures were approved by the ethical committee of Peking University.
Experiment Procedures
At the beginning of the experiments, subjects were told that there were four modalities in the acupuncture treatment and that the purpose of our research was to use fMRI to determine how the modalities changed brain functions. All subjects were recruited to participate in four fMRI scanning sessions, and in each session, the subjects received only one type of stimulation: MA, EA, TEAS or a sensory control. The four sessions were randomized and separated by a minimum of one week.
Acupuncture was performed at acupoint ST-36 on the left leg (Zusanli, located in the tibialis anterior muscle) and was performed by the same experienced and licensed acupuncturist. The needles used in the MA and EA sessions were sterile, disposable, stainless-steel acupuncture needles, which would not distort MR images, measuring 0.22 mm in diameter and 40 mm in length. The needle was inserted in ST-36 with a depth of 1.5–2.5 cm. In the MA session, stimulation was delivered by twisting the needle at 1–2 Hz. In the EA session, in addition to one needle in ST-36, another needle was shallowly inserted (less than 1 cm depth) to a non-acupoint proximal to ST-36. The same locations were attached with electrode slices to the skin surface in the TEAS session. Current was delivered by HANS (Han’s acupoint nerve stimulator, model LH-202H, Neuroscience Research Institute, Peking University, Beijing, China) with a frequency of 2 Hz in both the EA and TEAS sessions. The current intensity for each subject was adjusted to a maximal but comfortable level (2.16±0.20 mA for EA and 23.73±1.71 mA for TEAS). Manual tapping with a 5.88 von Frey monofilament over ST-36 with a 1–2 Hz frequency was utilized in the sensory control session, which is a maneuver that has often been chosen as a control stimulation in acupuncture studies [24], [29]. In all sessions, no sharp pain feeling was allowed.
Functional scanning was incorporated with three independent runs in each session. Two rest runs, each lasting 6 min, were separated by a 5.5 min block-designed run and a 5 min stimulation period (Fig. 1). During the scanning, subjects lay supine on the scanner bed, wearing ear plugs to suppress scanner noise and with the head immobilized by cushioned supports. They were instructed to keep their eyes closed and their minds clear and to remain awake. In addition, the feelings of deqi were collected at the end of the session, including soreness, numbness, fullness, heaviness and dull pain. Subjects were asked to rate each component of the deqi feeling they had experienced during the stimulation period using a visual analog scale (VAS) ranging from 0 (none) to 100 (max).
Functional scanning incorporated with three independent runs: two rest runs (rest 1 and rest 2), each lasting 6 min, were separated by a 5.5 min block-designed run and a 5 min stimulation period. The block-designed scanning included two cycles, 1 min stimulation (S1 and S2) and a 1 min rest epoch, preceded by a 1.5 min rest period as baseline (BL). Immediately after the block-designed run, the same modality of stimulation was continued for 5 min without scanning.
fMRI Data Acquisition
Functional images were acquired on a Siemens 3T whole-body scanner with a standard whole head coil. Blood oxygenation level-dependent (BOLD) functional imaging was conducted using a T2*-weighted single-shot, gradient-recalled echo planar imaging (EPI) sequence (TE = 30 ms, TR = 2 s, flip angle = 90°, FOV = 250 mm×250 mm). Twenty-nine axial sections, each measuring 4 mm in thickness with 1-mm inter-slices, were collected to encompass the whole cerebrum and cerebellum. Prior to the functional run in the first session, high-resolution structural images of each subject were acquired using a 3D T1-weighted sequence (TR/TE = 2.7s/3.19 ms, FOV = 256 mm×256 mm, flip angle = 7°, slice thickness = 1 mm).
fMRI Data Analysis
SPM5 software (Wellcome Department of Cognitive Neurology, London, UK) and Group ICA of the fMRI Toolbox (GIFT, http://icatb.sourceforge.net/) were used for the fMRI data analysis. For each run, all the functional images were first realigned to the first one. The image data were further processed with spatial normalization based on the Montreal Neurological Institute (MNI) template and resampled at 2 mm×2 mm×2 mm and spatially smoothed thereafter using a Gaussian Kernel with 6 mm full-width at half maximum (FWHM). Then these data were filtered to reduce the effect of low-frequency drift and high-frequency noise by using a band-pass filter (0.01–0.08 Hz).
To investigate the manipulation effect, GLM was used to analyze the block-designed data. Because the sustained effect of acupuncture has been shown to exist even after a very short period (1 min) of acupuncture stimulation [27], we utilized a modified GLM design matrix that separated different conditions across each subject with regressors coded for the difference between the baseline (BL) and the stimulation period (S1 and S2) (Fig. 1). Further statistical analyses were performed at both the individual level and the group level. In the individual analysis, two t-contrasts were defined as S1 minus BL and S2 minus BL. The resulting statistical maps indicated the voxel-wise signal changes for a specific stimulation condition relative to the baseline. These maps from each subject were later used to generate the group map using one sample t-test. Statistical significance was thresholded at cluster-level FDR corrected to P<0.05, with a cluster size of no less than 15 voxels.
To investigate the sustained effects of acupuncture, independent component analysis (ICA) was used to analyze the rest datasets. Using the Informax ICA algorithm, the smoothed rest data were separated into 40 independent components, and the number was estimated by minimum description length criteria. The DMN or SMN component was identified by spatially sorting the entire components with the corresponding mask [30]. Next, for each subject, the best-fit component was extracted from each individual run. One sample t-test with a significant level of voxel-level FDR corrected to P<0.05 was used to examine the group maps for the DMN and SMN, and these maps were made into masks for later comparisons. Paired t-tests were performed to determine the differences in the spatial extant of DMN/SMN between rest 1 versus rest 2 for each modality of stimulation, thresholded at voxel-wise of P<0.001 uncorrected with 15 continuous voxels within the masks.
Results
General Results of Experimental Performance
Sixteen of eighteen consenting volunteers completed the study, and two withdrew. In the functional data processing, data with head movements exceeding 1 mm on any axis or with a head rotation greater than 1° were excluded. In the final cohort, the block-designed datasets included 15 subjects for sensory control, 14 for MA, 15 for EA and 15 for TEAS. Meanwhile, there were 16 subjects for sensory control, 15 for MA, 15 for EA and 14 for TEAS in the rest datasets.
The percentage of the subjects who reported deqi feelings, including soreness, numbness, fullness, heaviness and dull pain, varied among different types of stimulation (Fig. 2). Compared to sensory control (F3,295 = 19.00, P<0.001), EA and MA showed higher fullness and heaviness reports. Stronger soreness and numbness feelings were specifically reported in MA and TEAS, respectively, and there were no differences in dull pain (Fig. 2B). The mean intensities of all sensations were also compared, and significant higher mean deqi scores were observed in MA and EA, compared to the sensory control (F3,62 = 7.252, P<0.001) (Fig. 2C).
A) The percentage of subjects who reported having experienced the feelings of deqi. B) The intensity of reported sensations measured by an average score (mean±SEM), tested with VAS from 0 to 100. Two-way ANOVA with Bonferroni post-tests were used. C) The mean intensity of all sensations, one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s multiple comparison tests were used. *, P<0.05, **, P<0.01, ***, P<0.001 compared to the sensory control.
Results of the Manipulation Effect
Group results during stimulation on ST-36 included two t-contrasts, S1 vs. BL and S2 vs. BL. For sensory control, both S1 and S2 produced signal increases in the sensorimotor area, prefrontal cortex and the cerebellum, and decreased BOLD signals were observed in the precuneus and the precentral gyrus. In addition to these areas, the insula, anterolateral prefrontal cortex, striatum and the middle temporal gyrus showed positive activation during S1 (Table 1). During MA on ST-36, S1 also increased the BOLD responses in the sensorimotor area, the anterolateral prefrontal cortex and the middle temporal gyrus. However, there was neither positive nor negative activation during S2 (Table 2). EA only activated the insula and the cerebellum in S1 but produced extensive signal decreases in the sensorimotor area, the limbic system, and other cortical regions such as the prefrontal cortex, superior temporal gyrus and the precuneus during S2 (Table 3). For TEAS, in addition to similar activations as in the sensory control, the premotor cortex, the thalamus and the parahippocampal gyrus showed specific signal changes in S1. There was no positive activation above the statistical threshold in S2, and deactivations were observed in the premotor area and the precuneus (Table 4).
Results of the Sustained Effect
The group maps of the DMN in the resting state consistently demonstrated spatial distribution with the DMN mask (Fig.S1A), including in the posterior cingulate, precuneus, medial prefrontal cortex and the inferior parietal lobule. Increased connectivity of this network was observed in the precuneus, middle occipital gyrus, temporal gyrus and the premotor cortex following MA stimulation. Additionally, the middle occipital gyrus, fusiform gyrus and the cerebellum also showed increased connectivity in EA. Decreased connectivity was found in the superior temporal gyrus following MA, in the inferior parietal lobule following EA and in the cuneus after EA and TEAS. There was no connectivity change in the sensory control (Table 5 and Fig. 3).
Using paired t-test. The threshold of display was set to voxel-wise P<0.001 uncorrected with at least 15 contiguous voxels. The colored bar indicates T-values. The group maps for the DMN before and after MA/EA stimulation were shown in Fig.S1A.
The group maps of the SMN during rest were also consistently spatially distributed with a predefined mask (Fig.S1B) and included the pre- and post-central gyrus, supplemental motor area and the secondary somatosensory area. MA, EA and the sensory control showed decreased connectivity in this network. Decreases were observed in the primary somatosensory area and the premotor cortex after MA, in the cuneus after EA, in the premotor cortex and the supplementary motor area after sensory control. However, TEAS predominantly increased connectivity in several regions, including the primary somatosensory area, the premotor cortex, the dorsal anterior cingulate cortex, the supplementary motor area, the superior temporal and the parietal lobule (Table 6 and Fig. 4).
Using paired t-test. The threshold of display was set to voxel-wise P<0.001 uncorrected, with at least 15 contiguous voxels. The colored bar indicates T-values. The group maps for the SMN before and after TEAS were shown in Fig.S1B.
Discussion
Although the manipulation effect of acupuncture on human brain activity has been studied for a long time, most of these studies have used block-designed datasets with typical GLM contrast analysis [15], [17], [24], [31]. However, it is well-known that the sustained effects of acupuncture could last for a long period of time after removing the needles [27], [32], [33]. Thus, the typical GLM analysis with block-design is inappropriate for identifying the manipulation effect on human brain activity from acupuncture. In the present study, only the 1.5 min rest period before stimulation was defined as the baseline (Fig. 1), and a modified GLM design matrix was used [27]. Thus, the manipulation effect can be observed without baseline contamination from other rest periods after acupuncture.
In our study, the sensory control stimulation induced similar brain activation during S1 and S2. The BOLD signal increases were mainly distributed in the sensory-motor areas and the lateral prefrontal cortex. The negative activation was observed in DMN (Table 1). These findings were mostly reported by other studies using 5.88 von Frey monofilaments as sensory controls [14], [24], [33]. In addition, the activation during S1 was more widespread than during S2, which could be attributed to habituation, a progressive decrease in the physiological response to a repeating stimulus that is neither rewarding nor harmful [34]. In contrast, for MA, EA and TEAS, group results during S1 and S2 displayed distinct patterns of activation. Similar positive activation in the sensory-motor area was observed during S1, but the BOLD responses during S2 trended to a negative activation pattern. In Table 2–4, no positive activation could be found in each of the three types of acupuncture stimulation during S2, and EA produced predominantly negative BOLD responses in brain regions, including the sensory-motor areas, the limbic system and other cortical gyri. It is in keeping with the findings that acupuncture stimulation evokes deactivation in the limbic-paralimbic-neocortical network [12], [13]. Although MA and TEAS exhibited absent or reduced deactivation during this period, we did observe sub-thresholded decreases in BOLD signal changes. Studies using a less strict level of significance also observed a trend of deactivation instead of activation during the S2 period in the MA group [27]. For pain-relief, EA has been shown to be more effective than MA, and TEAS was equally effective as EA [8], [9]. Furthermore, Napadow et al. reported that EA induced more widespread fMRI signal changes than MA when a traditional GLM with block design was used [24]. The current findings indicate that, inconsistent with the sensory habituation in the control, the manipulation effect of all the three modalities of acupuncture stimulation was an early somatosensory activation with later cortical-subcortical deactivation, and EA produced more obvious deactivation than MA and TEAS.
Recently, more studies have paid close attention to the sustained after-effects of acupuncture by comparing the resting state connectivity before and after acupuncture. To the best of our knowledge, most of these studies used short periods of stimulation of less than 6 min [20], [21], [22], [35], which does not fully model the clinical effect produced by relatively longer periods of acupuncture [3]. An early study from our research group revealed a time-curve for the analgesic effect of MA in healthy human beings, and the skin pain threshold started to increase after approximately 10 min of treatment [36]. For this reason, 5 more minutes of stimulation were added after the block to make our model more appropriate for the explanation of the mechanism of potential acupuncture treatment effects.
Interestingly, in the present study, the resting state network following TEAS stimulation displayed a different pattern of connectivity changes than MA and EA. As shown in Table 5 and Fig. 3, the modulating effect of MA and EA is predominantly through the DMN, whereas a more secure and spatially extended connectivity of the SMN was specifically detected in the post-TEAS rest (Table 6 and Fig. 4). Similar increased connectivity between the DMN with other brain regions including the temporal, occipital and frontal cortex were also reported in other studies using MA [21], [28], [37] and EA [38]. This modulatory effect is speculated to be potent in treating diseases with dysfunctional DMN, such as pain, substance abuse and Alzheimer’s disease [39], [40], [41], [42], [43]. Additionally, a recent study reported that although EA had a better analgesic effect than MA, a sustained effect was better produced by MA [9], which might explain the more extended increased connectivity in cortical regions induced by MA in our work. To the best of our knowledge, there has been little research investigating the sustained effect following TEAS, and in this study, we first discovered this specific SMN modulating effect. Dhond et al. reported that MA could also increase the functional connectivity in SMN in several regions by acupuncture in PC-6, but the predominant changes were still focused on the DMN [21]. Recently, long-term transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) was shown to be effective in reorganizing the motor cortex in a neurologically intact human, which highlights the potential benefit of sensory training by TENS as a useful complementary therapy in neurorehabilitation [44]. Thus, we surmised that TEAS might be specifically sensitive in the SMN, and this transcutaneous acupuncture might be more suitable for treating diseases with sensory dysfunction. It is notable that our recent work showed that when the stimulation period lasts 30 min, in addition to the SMN modulatory effect, TEAS could also increase the functional connectivity in the DMN [18]. This finding indicated that the effect of acupuncture may have been dependent on the duration of the stimulation and that the treatment time should be considered to be an important factor for studies on the mechanisms of acupuncture.
The sensations of deqi were different in the three modalities of acupuncture stimulation; MA and EA produced stronger deqi sensations of fullness and heaviness than did the control (Fig. 2), and stronger soreness was also reported in MA. Interestingly, unlike MA and EA, TEAS specifically induced more reports of numbness. Because the deqi sensation is considered to be related to the clinical efficacy in traditional Chinese medicine [45], [46], our results suggested that different types of acupuncture treatment, especially the transcutaneous and invasive acupuncture, might have varied treatment effects, and further studies are required to support this speculation. Moreover, no difference was observed in dull pain sensation between the acupuncture and control groups, which confirmed deqi as a multiple-feeling sensation more than only pain [24], [47].
Several limitations in this study should be noted. Although we observed differences among different acupuncture modalities in deqi sensation and in the effects on brain activities by using fMRI, less information about autonomic response was collected (for instance, heart rate and skin conductance). Napadow et al. recently reported that different brain responses underling MA stimulation may be related to differential autonomic outflows and may result from heterogeneity in evoked sensations [29]. In addition, a recent report by Florian et al. provided an insight into the linkage of the deqi sensation, autonomic responses and the potential of therapeutic effect [48]. Thus, it is possible that the differences in brain activity changes induced by different acupuncture modalities might also have a relationship with the autonomic responses. To study this possibility further, combined fMRI and autonomic response measurements are needed. It also should be noted that the present study focused primarily on changes in brain activity induced by acupuncture in healthy subjects and could only provide clues in exploring the mechanisms of acupuncture treatment. Further studies in patients would provide more convincing evidence of the differences among these modalities of acupuncture. Also, the significant threshold of the paired-t test was without FDR corrected, further researches with large sample size may conquer this limitation.
In summary, the current study suggests that although different modalities of acupuncture could be clinically effective, the underlining mechanisms might be varied, and acupuncture in differential modalities might have treatment potentials for specific dysfunctions. In addition, the findings of our research could supply methodological information for further studies examining the mechanism of acupuncture.
Supporting Information
Figure S1.
Group maps for the DMN and the SMN, before and after acupuncture stimulation. The best-fit components were selected by using the templates of the DMN and SMN shown in the right line of the graph. The group results of (A) the DMN and (B) the SMN components decomposed by ICA included the pre-MA rest/post-MA rest, the pre-EA rest/post-EA rest and the pre-TEAS rest/post-TEAS rest. The threshold of one sample t-test was set as FDR corrected, P<0.05, with at least 10 continuous voxels in all group statistics. Color bar indicates T-values.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0066815.s001
(DOC)
Author Contributions
Conceived and designed the experiments: YJ CLC JSH. Performed the experiments: YJ YRD YD HW XHX LZW. Analyzed the data: YJ ZYL LJB JT. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: HW. Wrote the paper: YJ CLC.
References
- 1.
NIH Consensus Conference (1998) Acupuncture. 1518–1524.
- 2. Xiang X, Jiang Y, Ni Y, Fan M, Shen F, et al. (2012) Catechol-O-methyltransferase polymorphisms do not play a significant role in pain perception in male Chinese Han population. Physiol Genomics 44: 318–328.
- 3. Han JS (2011) Acupuncture analgesia: Areas of consensus and controversy. Pain 152: 41–48.
- 4. Cui CL, Wu LZ, Luo F (2008) Acupuncture for the treatment of drug addiction. Neurochem Res 33: 2013–2022.
- 5. Unterrainer AF, Friedrich C, Krenn MH, Piotrowski WP, Golaszewski SM, et al. (2010) Postoperative and preincisional electrical nerve stimulation TENS reduce postoperative opioid requirement after major spinal surgery. J Neurosurg Anesthesiol 22: 1–5.
- 6. Zhang R, Feng XJ, Guan Q, Cui W, Zheng Y, et al. (2011) Increase of success rate for women undergoing embryo transfer by transcutaneous electrical acupoint stimulation: a prospective randomized placebo-controlled study. Fertil Steril 96: 912–916.
- 7. Zhang R, Jia MX, Zhang JS, Xu XJ, Shou XJ, et al. (2012) Transcutaneous electrical acupoint stimulation in children with autism and its impact on plasma levels of arginine-vasopressin and oxytocin: a prospective single-blinded controlled study. Res Dev Disabil 33: 1136–1146.
- 8. Ulett GA, Han S, Han JS (1998) Electroacupuncture: mechanisms and clinical application. Biol Psychiatry 44: 129–138.
- 9. Schliessbach J, van der Klift E, Arendt-Nielsen L, Curatolo M, Streitberger K (2011) The effect of brief electrical and manual acupuncture stimulation on mechanical experimental pain. Pain Med 12: 268–275.
- 10. Wang JQ, Mao L, Han JS (1992) Comparison of the antinociceptive effects induced by electroacupuncture and transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation in the rat. Int J Neurosci 65: 117–129.
- 11. Han JS (2003) Acupuncture: neuropeptide release produced by electrical stimulation of different frequencies. Trends Neurosci 26: 17–22.
- 12.
Hui KK, Marina O, Liu J, Rosen BR, Kwong KK (2010) Acupuncture, the limbic system, and the anticorrelated networks of the brain. Auton Neurosci.
- 13. Fang J, Jin Z, Wang Y, Li K, Kong J, et al. (2009) The salient characteristics of the central effects of acupuncture needling: limbic-paralimbic-neocortical network modulation. Hum Brain Mapp 30: 1196–1206.
- 14. Hui KK, Liu J, Marina O, Napadow V, Haselgrove C, et al. (2005) The integrated response of the human cerebro-cerebellar and limbic systems to acupuncture stimulation at ST 36 as evidenced by fMRI. Neuroimage 27: 479–496.
- 15. Zhang WT, Jin Z, Cui GH, Zhang KL, Zhang L, et al. (2003) Relations between brain network activation and analgesic effect induced by low vs. high frequency electrical acupoint stimulation in different subjects: a functional magnetic resonance imaging study. Brain Res 982: 168–178.
- 16. Wu MT, Sheen JM, Chuang KH, Yang P, Chin SL, et al. (2002) Neuronal specificity of acupuncture response: a fMRI study with electroacupuncture. Neuroimage 16: 1028–1037.
- 17. Hui KK, Liu J, Makris N, Gollub RL, Chen AJ, et al. (2000) Acupuncture modulates the limbic system and subcortical gray structures of the human brain: evidence from fMRI studies in normal subjects. Hum Brain Mapp 9: 13–25.
- 18.
Jiang Y, Hao Y, Zhang Y, Liu J, Wang X, et al.. (2012) Thirty minute transcutaneous electric acupoint stimulation modulates resting state brain activities: A perfusion and BOLD fMRI study. Brain Res.
- 19. Liu B, Chen J, Wang J, Liu X, Duan X, et al. (2012) Altered Small-World Efficiency of Brain Functional Networks in Acupuncture at ST36: A Functional MRI Study. PLoS One 7: e39342.
- 20. Bai L, Qin W, Tian J, Dong M, Pan X, et al. (2009) Acupuncture modulates spontaneous activities in the anticorrelated resting brain networks. Brain Res 1279: 37–49.
- 21. Dhond RP, Yeh C, Park K, Kettner N, Napadow V (2008) Acupuncture modulates resting state connectivity in default and sensorimotor brain networks. Pain 136: 407–418.
- 22. Qin W, Tian J, Bai L, Pan X, Yang L, et al. (2008) FMRI connectivity analysis of acupuncture effects on an amygdala-associated brain network. Mol Pain 4: 55.
- 23. Huang W, Pach D, Napadow V, Park K, Long X, et al. (2012) Characterizing acupuncture stimuli using brain imaging with FMRI - a systematic review and meta-analysis of the literature. PLoS One 7: e32960.
- 24. Napadow V, Makris N, Liu J, Kettner NW, Kwong KK, et al. (2005) Effects of electroacupuncture versus manual acupuncture on the human brain as measured by fMRI. Hum Brain Mapp 24: 193–205.
- 25. Li G, Cheung RT, Ma QY, Yang ES (2003) Visual cortical activations on fMRI upon stimulation of the vision-implicated acupoints. Neuroreport 14: 669–673.
- 26. Kong J, Ma L, Gollub RL, Wei J, Yang X, et al. (2002) A pilot study of functional magnetic resonance imaging of the brain during manual and electroacupuncture stimulation of acupuncture point (LI-4 Hegu) in normal subjects reveals differential brain activation between methods. J Altern Complement Med 8: 411–419.
- 27. Bai L, Qin W, Tian J, Liu P, Li L, et al. (2009) Time-varied characteristics of acupuncture effects in fMRI studies. Hum Brain Mapp 30: 3445–3460.
- 28. Hui KKS, Marina O, Claunch JD, Nixon EE, Fang J, et al. (2009) Acupuncture mobilizes the brain's default mode and its anti-correlated network in healthy subjects. Brain Research 1287: 84–103.
- 29.
Napadow V, Lee J, Kim J, Cina S, Maeda Y, et al.. (2012) Brain correlates of phasic autonomic response to acupuncture stimulation: An event-related fMRI study. Hum Brain Mapp.
- 30. Franco AR, Pritchard A, Calhoun VD, Mayer AR (2009) Interrater and intermethod reliability of default mode network selection. Hum Brain Mapp 30: 2293–2303.
- 31. Napadow V, Dhond R, Park K, Kim J, Makris N, et al. (2009) Time-variant fMRI activity in the brainstem and higher structures in response to acupuncture. Neuroimage 47: 289–301.
- 32. Price DD, Rafii A, Watkins LR, Buckingham B (1984) A psychophysical analysis of acupuncture analgesia. Pain 19: 27–42.
- 33. Napadow V, Dhond RP, Kim J, LaCount L, Vangel M, et al. (2009) Brain encoding of acupuncture sensation–coupling on-line rating with fMRI. Neuroimage 47: 1055–1065.
- 34. Thompson RF, Spencer WA (1966) Habituation: a model phenomenon for the study of neuronal substrates of behavior. Psychol Rev 73: 16–43.
- 35. Liu J, Qin W, Guo Q, Sun J, Yuan K, et al. (2010) Distinct brain networks for time-varied characteristics of acupuncture. Neurosci Lett 468: 353–358.
- 36.
Research Group Of Acupuncture Anesthesia PMC (1973) The effect of acupuncture on the human skin pain threshold.: Chin Med J. 151–157.
- 37.
Zhong C, Bai L, Dai R, Xue T, Wang H, et al.. (2011) Modulatory effects of acupuncture on resting-state networks: A functional MRI study combining independent component analysis and multivariate granger causality analysis. J Magn Reson Imaging.
- 38. Liu P, Zhang Y, Zhou G, Yuan K, Qin W, et al. (2009) Partial correlation investigation on the default mode network involved in acupuncture: an fMRI study. Neurosci Lett 462: 183–187.
- 39. Zyloney CE, Jensen K, Polich G, Loiotile RE, Cheetham A, et al. (2010) Imaging the functional connectivity of the Periaqueductal Gray during genuine and sham electroacupuncture treatment. Mol Pain 6: 80.
- 40. Zhang Y, Tian J, Yuan K, Liu P, Zhuo L, et al. (2011) Distinct resting-state brain activities in heroin-dependent individuals. Brain Res 1402: 46–53.
- 41. Ma N, Liu Y, Fu XM, Li N, Wang CX, et al. (2011) Abnormal brain default-mode network functional connectivity in drug addicts. PLoS One 6: e16560.
- 42. Baliki MN, Geha PY, Apkarian AV, Chialvo DR (2008) Beyond feeling: chronic pain hurts the brain, disrupting the default-mode network dynamics. J Neurosci 28: 1398–1403.
- 43. Wang Z, Nie B, Li D, Zhao Z, Han Y, et al. (2012) Effect of acupuncture in mild cognitive impairment and Alzheimer disease: a functional MRI study. PLoS One 7: e42730.
- 44. Meesen RL, Cuypers K, Rothwell JC, Swinnen SP, Levin O (2011) The effect of long-term TENS on persistent neuroplastic changes in the human cerebral cortex. Hum Brain Mapp 32: 872–882.
- 45.
Cheng X (1997) Chinese Acupuncture and Moxibustion.
- 46. Hui KK, Sporko TN, Vangel MG, Li M, Fang J, et al. (2011) Perception of Deqi by Chinese and American acupuncturists: a pilot survey. Chin Med 6: 2.
- 47. Kong J, Gollub R, Huang T, Polich G, Napadow V, et al. (2007) Acupuncture de qi, from qualitative history to quantitative measurement. J Altern Complement Med 13: 1059–1070.
- 48.
Beissner F, Deichmann R, Henke C, Bar KJ (2011) Acupuncture - Deep pain with an autonomic dimension? Neuroimage.