Figures
Abstract
This work has studied for the first time the structure and diversity of plant-parasitic nematodes (PPNs) infesting olive orchard soils in a wide-region in Spain that included 92 locations. It aims at determining which agronomical or environmental factors associated to the olive orchards are the main drivers of the PPNs community structure and diversity. Classical morphological and morphometric identification methods were used to determine the frequency and densities of PPNs. Thirteen families, 34 genera and 77 species of PPNs were identified. The highest diversity was found in Helicotylenchus genus, with six species previously reported in Spain and with H. oleae being a first report. Neodolichorhynchus microphasmis and Diptenchus sp., Diphtherophora sp., and Discotylenchus sp., usually considered fungal feeders, were also reported for the first time associated to olive rhizosphere. PPNs abundance ranged from 66 to 16,288 individuals/500-cm3 of soil with Helicotylenchus digonicus being the most prevalent species, followed by Filenchus sp., Merlinius brevidens and Xiphinema pachtaicum. Nematode abundance and diversity indexes were influenced by olive cultivar, and orchard and soil management practices; while olive variety and soil texture were the main factors driving PPN community composition. Soil physicochemical properties and climatic characteristics most strongly associated to the PPN community composition included pH, sand content and exchangeable K, and maximum and minimum average temperature of the sampled locations. Our data suggests that there is a high diversity of PPNs associated to olive in Southern Spain that can exert different damage to olive roots depending on the olive variety and their abundance. Further analysis to determine the resistance levels of most common olive varieties to the prevalent PPNs in Spain will help to choose the most appropriate ones for the establishment of new plantations. This choice will take into consideration the specific soils and environments where those olive varieties will be established.
Citation: Palomares-Rius JE, Castillo P, Montes-Borrego M, Navas-Cortés JA, Landa BB (2015) Soil Properties and Olive Cultivar Determine the Structure and Diversity of Plant-Parasitic Nematode Communities Infesting Olive Orchards Soils in Southern Spain. PLoS ONE 10(1): e0116890. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0116890
Academic Editor: Philippe Castagnone-Sereno, INRA, FRANCE
Received: September 5, 2014; Accepted: December 16, 2014; Published: January 27, 2015
Copyright: © 2015 Palomares-Rius et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the paper and its Supporting Information files.
Funding: Financial support was received by Projects AGL2008-00344/AGR from ‘Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación’, Project AGL-2012-37521 from ‘Ministerio de Economía y Competitividad’ of Spain and Projects P10-AGR-5908 and P12-AGR-1486 from ‘Consejería de Economía, Innovación y Ciencia’ of Junta de Andalucía, and FEDER financial support from the European Union is gratefully acknowledged. The grant 219262 ArimNET_ERANET FP7 2012-2015 Project PESTOLIVE ‘Contribution of olive history for the management of soilborne parasites in the Mediterranean basin’ from Instituto Nacional de Investigación y Tecnología Agraria y Alimentaria (INIA), and the ‘Internacional del Aceite de Oliva Español-Citoliva’ also provided partial financial support. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Introduction
Historically, and to the present times cultivated olive (Olea europaea L. subsp. europaea L.) has been culturally and economically very significant for the Mediterranean and Middle Eastern regions and remains integral to the economy of the Mediterranean area (e.g., Spain produces around 1/2 of the world production of olive oil, generating 1,886 million €) [1, 2]. Furthermore, olive orchards comprise a valuable ecological landscape determining the profitability, living and working conditions, and environmental quality of those territories. Nowadays, olive orchards cover about 10.2 M ha in the world, mainly in the Mediterranean Basin, of which more than 2.5 million ha of olives are located in Spain, mostly under rain fed production systems and 90% of them dedicated to oil production in 2012 [1, 3]. In particular, 68% of the Spanish cultivation of olives are located in Andalusia, southern Spain, occupying >1.6 M ha accounting for 19% of the total surface area of Andalusia in an impressive monoculture [1, 4].
In Andalusia, where olive production is enormously important for both economic and ecological reasons, three main olive cropping systems can be differentiated including: (i) agroforestry stands where many olive orchards are confined to slopes or rugged land, occupying large parts of mountains and hills of the Mediterranean landscape, (ii) traditional groves located in rolling plains, with gentler slopes, deeper and better soils, normally rain fed, with low plant density (less than 100 olive trees/ha), intensive tillage, low inputs in fertilizer and pesticides and manual harvest, and (iii) new intensive orchards where traditional groves are being adapted or progressively substituted by high plant density (200–400 olive trees/ha), drip-irrigated plantations, with reduced tillage, high inputs of pesticides and fertilizers and mechanical harvesting in order to push up olive yields [5, 6]. Additionally, olive production has become an example of the world-wide trend towards environmentally friendly agricultural strategies, so that new management systems such as integrated production and organic farming are being promoted to reduce negative environmental impacts of excessive use of pesticides and fertilizers. Indeed, in the last two decades it there has been a growing demand for organic olive oil which has resulted in the adoption by farmers of organic production in many traditional olive growing areas of Spain, Italy, Portugal, and Greece [7]. In Andalusia southern Spain, the cultivation of the olive under the guidelines of organic management has increased by 30% from 2006 to 2012, exceeding 54,800 ha of organic olive groves in 2012 [4], most of them (over 40%) being located in the province of Córdoba.
Some studies have shown that the shift to organic production, in parallel with an increase in use of cover crops and mechanical mowing, may enhance sustainability of olive production in the traditional olive-growing areas of Andalusia, mainly through increased soil conservation and improvement of soil physicochemical and biological properties [8–11]. However, the potential impact that those changes in the olive cropping system might have on biological soil properties, including changes in populations of soilborne pathogens of olive crop remains unknown.
Olive crop production in the Mediterranean area can be threatened by different diseases, mainly of fungal aetiology, which may result in a reduction in olive yields and plant vigor and/or longevity. Furthermore, modern olive production systems based largely on the establishment of new orchards under high-input schemes may create an environment more conducive to plant-parasitic nematode (PPN) diseases [12–14]. However, the specific negative effect on plant growth and yield by PPNs parasitism that may result from the disruption that they cause to normal processes of plant root growth and function have not been studied in detail [15]. This may be mainly due to the fact that damage to established olive orchards by nematode parasitism may be not clearly perceived by farmers since olive is an extremely vigorous plant able to thrive in relatively dry areas, which may jeopardize expression of symptoms from PPNs attacks [12]. Thus, water stress and nutrient deficiencies resulting from damage in the plant root system that can be major consequences of PPNs attacks may not be perceived by farmers or if so attributed to other soilborne plant pathogens or to poor soil quality.
Olive trees serve as hosts to a large number of PPNs, of which root-knot nematodes (Meloidogyne spp.), root-lesion nematodes (Pratylenchus spp.), spiral nematodes (Helicotylenchus spp.), and Criconemoides xenoplax are widely distributed [12, 16–18]. Conversely, limited distribution on olive has been reported for the citrus (Tylenchulus semipenetrans) and the cyst-forming (Heterodera mediterranea) nematodes [19, 20]. Some of these nematodes are recognized as pathogenic to olive (Meloidogyne sp., Pratylenchus sp., Tylenchulus semipenetrans and Heterodera mediterranea) [12, 16]. Over 150 species of PPNs have been reported in association with olive [16–18, 21], including other genera than those previously cited above, such as Amplimerlinius spp., Aorolaimus spp., Paratrichodorus spp., Paratylenchus spp., Pratylenchoides spp., Trichodorus spp., Tylenchorhynchus spp., Xiphinema spp. [17–18, 22]. However, there is a lack of information whether the PPN populations infesting olive soils apart from the phytopathological interest may be a useful bioindicator of soil health and of olive orchard or soil management systems [23]. In fact, soil disturbance has been positively correlated with the abundance and diversity of PPNs or the Plant Parasitic Index (PPI) [24]. Also, increased nutrient uptake by plants seems to cause a shift within the population composition of the PPNs [25]. Thus, knowledge of PPN species distribution, together with data on nematode population densities and structure in rhizospheric soil of cultivated olives, and the effects that farm management system may have on those populations would be useful for the management of the diseases that they might cause, as well as for helping to choose the most appropriate management system. Therefore, the objectives of this study were to determine: (i) the identity, frequency, and population density of PPNs infesting olive orchard soils in a wide area of Andalusia, Southern Spain, and (ii) to evaluate the influence that abiotic factors (including climate and soil physicochemical properties) and agronomic factors (including orchard and soil management systems, olive cultivar, irrigation regime and age of plantation) may have on the frequency and population densities and structure of those nematodes.
Material and Methods
Ethics Statement
No specific permits were required for the described field studies. Permission for sampling the olive orchards were granted by the landowner. The 92 olive orchards sampled in this study have been included in previous studies [10, 26] aimed to study bacterial and mycorrhizal communities and functional diversity of the olive rhizosphere. The sites are not protected in any way. The areas studied do not involve any species endangered or protected in Spain.
Soil collection and nematode extraction
Soil samples were collected from May to July 2009 in 89 commercial olive orchards and three locations containing wild or feral forms of olive (‘Acebuches’) at southern Spain. From the commercial olive orchards, 47 are under conventional, and 42 are under organic management systems. Sampling procedures, specific location and a detailed description of the orchard sampled have recently been provided [10, 26] and also are included in S1 Table. In each olive orchard eight trees were randomly selected for soil sampling. Soil samples were collected with a shovel discarding the upper 5-cm top soil profile, from a 5- to 40-cm depth, in the close vicinity of active olive roots. This ensured that roots from weeds or other herbaceous plants were unlikely sampled. All soil samples from all trees of each olive orchard were thoroughly mixed to obtain a single representative sample per orchard before nematode extraction. This sampling strategy allowed obtaining an estimation of the most frequent PPNs that are closely associated to olive rhizosphere. Soil parameters used in the study included soil organic matter (SOM), organic C, organic N, C:N ratio, extractable P, exchangeable K, cation exchange capacity (CEC), pH (KCl), clay (%) and Sand (%) and have been reported before [26].
Nematodes from the soil were extracted from a 500-cm3 sub-sample using the magnesium sulphate centrifugal-flotation method [27]. Briefly, the soil was washed thoroughly with tap water through a 710-μm mesh sieve, and the filtered water was collected in a beaker and thoroughly mixed with 4% kaolin (v/v). This mixture was centrifuged at 1,100×g for 4 min, and then the supernatants were discarded. Pellets were resuspended in 250 ml MgSO4 (δ = 1.16) and the new suspensions were centrifuged at 1,100×g for 3 min. Supernatants were sieved through a 5 μm mesh, and nematodes collected on the sieve were washed with tap water, transferred to a cross-linked 8 × 8 cm square counting plate where the total number of PPNs per sample was counted under the stereomicroscope at 50xmagnification using a hand-tally counter [27]. The extracted nematodes were identified by selecting adult nematode specimens of separate genera which were fixed in 4% formaldehyde, processed to glycerin [28], and identified by morphological traits to genus or species level.
Diversity indices
Abundance of nematodes, and the Richness, Shannon and Evenness diversity indexes were calculated using the vegan version 1.17–6 package [29] with the R version 3.0.1 software (R Core Development Team). Additionally, the plant parasitic index (PPI) for plant feeding nematodes was calculated according to Bongers [30] as Σ vi x fi, where vi is the c-p value of taxon i in each olive orchard listed in Table 1, and fi is the frequency of that taxon in a sample.
Association between the distribution of plant-parasitic nematodes from olive and abiotic and agronomic characteristic of olive orchards
Each of the 89 commercial olive orchards and 3 wild olive locations sampled were characterized for the presence, identity and frequency of PPNs. The different environmental and agronomic factors that characterize each of the 92 olive orchards and wild olive locations sampled in Andalusia were reported in a previous study [26]. The rank-based Kruskall-Wallis test was used to determine differences in all estimated diversity indexes in relation to the different agronomic factors of the olive orchards evaluated using the NPAR1WAY procedure of the Statistical Analysis System software package (SAS version 9.4; SAS Institute, Cary, NC, USA). Multiple pairwise comparisons between orchard management systems (OMS), soil management systems (SMS) and cultivar levels were determined by the Dunn test due to the unequal sample size or tied sample ranks using the KW_MC macro for SAS [31]. Correlation between diversity indexes was estimated using the Kendall tau b correlation coefficient (Ʈken,b) (calculated with the CORR procedure of SAS. The Ʈken,b was also used to estimate the correlation between abundant PPNs species.
Unsupervised cluster analysis based on the Bray-Curtis dissimilarity using the Ward’s Minimum Variance Clustering method was calculated as a preliminary step towards inferring any structure in the PPN populations among olive orchard soils sampled. The optimum number of clusters and the degree of membership of an olive orchard to its cluster was estimated on the basis of the maximum average silhouette width according to K-means partitioning. Those analyses were performed using the cluster package version 1.15.2 [32] with the R software.
Non-metric multidimensional scaling (NMDS) analyses were performed using MetaMDS function within the vegan package of R software based on dissimilarities calculated using the Bray–Curtis index obtained for data of nematode frequency, using 1,000 runs with random starting configurations, and environmental variables (agronomic and climatic characteristics and soil physicochemical properties) were fitted using the envfit routine. Also a Multivariate Regression Tree (MRT) was calculated to explore, describe, and predict relationships between multispecies data and environmental characteristics [33]. The MRT was calculated within the mvpart version 1.6–2 package with the R software, using the one-standard error rule on the cross-validated relative error to determine the number of terminal nodes [33].
Results and Discussion
Diversity and identity of Plant-parasitic nematodes infecting olive orchards
Morphological and morphometric studies of diagnostic characters allowed the identification of 13 families, 34 genera and 77 species of PPNs associated with olive orchard soils in southern Spain, including 10 species identified at genus level (viz. Basiria sp., Diphtherophora sp., Diptenchus sp., Discotylenchus sp., Ditylenchus sp., Filenchus sp., Longidorus sp., Neopsilenchus sp., Psilenchus sp., and Tylenchus sp.) (Table 1). Among them, spiral, stunt, pin, root-lesion and ring nematodes were the most abundant (Table 1). The highest diversity was found in the spiral nematode genus Helicotylenchus with 7 species, viz. H. canadensis, H. digonicus, H. dihystera, H. exallus, H. oleae, H. pseudorobustus, and H. vulgaris (Table 1), which were previously reported in Spain [34] with the exception of H. oleae which is reported associated to olive rhizosphere for the first time. Overall, the total number of PPNs in each orchard ranged from 66 (field S2) to 16,288 (field S29) individuals/500-cm3 soil and their percentage respect the total of PPNs in a sample ranged from 0.02% (Trichodorus giennensis) to 98.50% (Helicotylenchus digonicus) (data not shown). Helicotylenchus digonicus was the most prevalent PPN (measured as the percentage of orchards in which the PPN species was found), and was found in 78.26% of olive orchards, followed by Filenchus sp., Merlinius brevidens and Xiphinema pachtaicum present in 64.13%, 63.04% and 58.70% of the orchards, respectively. The frequency of the remaining species ranged from 1.09 to 42.39, with 55 of them being found in less than 10% of the sampled orchards (Table 1).
The majority of the more abundant nematode species found in this study have been associated with olive trees in previous studies [12, 16, 21]. However, some nematode genera identified in this work had not been cited previously and constitute the first report of their association to olive rhizosphere [12, 16, 21]. Those genera included the fungal feeders Diptenchus, Diphtherophora, and Discotylenchus, and the PPN genus Neodolichorhynchus [35], although these nematodes occurred rarely. Interestingly, most species considered particularly damaging PPNs were detected only in single fields and at a low density: Heterodera mediterranea, Meloidogyne arenaria and M. artiellia. Heterodera mediterranea is a highly specialized nematode associated with cultivated and wild olives forming syncytia and inducing a disorder in the stellar structures [36–37]. Meloidogyne arenaria has been also previously associated with olive in Spain [12, 36]. Meloidogyne artiellia could be associated with cultivated and wild grasses and legumes growing as cover crops in the sampled orchards rather than with olive; as olive is not a suitable host for this PPN species [38]. Four Pratylenchus species were identified associated to olive rhizosphere in our study (Table 1). Of them only P. penetrans is particularly damaging to olive. In fact, from the wide number of Pratylenchus species associated with olive, only this species together with P. vulnus have been demonstrated to be pathogenic to olive in plant bioassays in artificial inoculations [39–41]. Recently, P. oleae that was not observed in this work has been described infecting roots of wild and cultivated olives suffering tree decline in southern Spain and Tunisia [42].
Diversity indexes
Several diversity indexes were estimated in our study (nematode abundance, Richness, Shannon and Evenness diversity indexes, and PPI; Fig. 1, S1 Table) and tested for differences associated to the agronomical characteristics of the olive orchards sampled (Fig. 1). Overall, abundance of PPNs was significantly and directly correlated (Ʈken,b >0.2255, n = 92, P < 0.0016) with the Richness and PPI indexes, while this correlation was inverse (Ʈken,b < -0.1822, n = 92, P < 0.0100) with the Shannon and Evenness indexes (data not shown). Soil species diversity tends to increase with increasing resource availability, which may explain that those samples supporting higher abundance of PPNs show higher Richness and PPI indexes [43]. Globally, the PPN abundance and Richness indexes were more effective in detecting significant differences (P < 0.05) between levels of the studied agronomic characteristics.
(A) Orchard management systems included: A = Wild olives or ‘Acebuches’, O = Organic management; C = Conventional management. (B) Soil management systems included: CC = Conventional management with cover crop, CT = Conventional management with tillage, OC = Organic management with cover crop, and OT = Organic management with tillage. (C) Soil texture. (D) Olive cultivar. The rank-based Kruskall-Wallis test was used to determine differences in all estimated diversity indexes in relation to the different agronomic factors and the resulting probability values are shown. For each agronomic parameter and diversity index, boxes with a different letter indicate significant differences (P < 0.05) according to multiple pairwise comparisons between OMS, SMS, soil texture and olive cultivar levels determined by the Dunn test. (*) ‘Lucentino’ was present in only one orchard and was not included in the statistical analyses.
The OMS significantly (P < 0.05) influenced PPN abundance and Richness index, while no significant differences (P≥0.05) occurred for the remaining three diversity indices tested (Fig. 1A,B). The PPN abundance was significantly higher (P = 0.0164) in orchards managed organically (O) compared to that managed conventionally (C), and the opposite occurred for the Richness index (P = 0.0003). Wild olives (A), showed intermediate values for both PPN diversity indexes that did not differ (P≥0.05) from those under O or C management (Fig. 1A). Our results obtained for PPN species are in agreement with that obtained by García-Ruiz et al. [44] for a limited set of olive orchards in which they analyzed the global nematofauna (including both free-living and PPN nematodes). Only one orchard from three sites sampled in Andalusia showed differences due to the management (organic versus conventional) for mean Richness index of plant and unicellular eukaryote feeding and omnivorous nematodes [44]. In previous studies focused in the same olive orchards sampled here we found that in general olive orchards under organic management showed higher microbial diversity in the rhizosphere as compared to conventionally managed orchards [10], however the structure and diversity of arbuscular mycorrhiza in the olive rhizosphere did not differ among OMS [26]. These findings could be the result of the influence of the herbaceous plants that compose the soil cover which may affect PPNs at the species level as suggested by Neher [45], since plant functional groups (i.e., grasses, legumes) have contrasting rooting patterns that create habitats more favorable to some species of PPNs such as ecto-parasites. Furthermore, SOM, organic C, organic N, C:N ratio were significantly higher in organic as compared to conventional management in the same orchards of this study [10]. Our results agree with previous reports of the existence of a higher number and diversity of PPNs in fields managed organically [46–49], however the lack of clear differences in abundance or diversity indexes of soil biota in other studies is attributed to the fact that soil type in general had a much stronger effect on the soil biota compared to orchard or farm management type [48, 50–51].
Soil management has a similar trend than OMS (Fig. 1B). Among SMS, the highest abundance (P = 0.0363) and Richness of PPN (P < 0.0001) occurred in organic olive orchards with the presence of a cover crop (OC), decreasing (P < 0.05) in orchards under either organic (OT) or conventional management with tillage (CT); being significantly lowest (P < 0.05) in orchards under conventional management with the presence of a cover crop (OC) (Fig. 1B). In our study, the presence of a cover crop in organic managed orchards might have increased the number and diversity of PPNs probably due to the presence of a food source during the whole crop season and the existence of different niches in the soil in a perennial crop as olive, whereas in the conventional orchards the application of herbicide to control weeds in late spring to early summer might have had a detrimental effect on PPN populations [52]. Nevertheless, it should be noticed that PPN species can respond differently to tillage. Thus, some PPNs genera have shown a great sensitivity to soil tillage, at least immediately after its application (i.e. Pratylenchus, Meloidogyne) [53]. This might explain that several studies have found different effects of tillage on nematode abundance and diversity [53–56]. Furthermore, it should be taken into account that tillage or the presence of a cover crop not only affect PPNs directly, but also have indirect effects by impacting on natural enemies that could regulate nematode populations [53]. Since the use of cover crops have been recently introduced to minimize soil erosion, a major problem of olive orchard soils [7–8], care should be taken to avoid cover crops that might enhance or contribute to maintain PPN populations detrimental to olive. On the other hand selection of specific cover crops have been shown as a promising technique in organic farming for controlling populations of PPNs and improving soil properties [57].
Soil texture modified both, abundance (P = 0.0055) and diversity (Shannon and Evenness indices) (P < 0.0206) of PPNs but with opposite trends (Fig. 1C). Indeed, although nematode abundance was significantly higher in clay loam soils, their higher diversity was reached on sandy loam soils that showed the lower nematode abundance (Fig. 1C). No significant differences (P > 0.3707) were observed for the Richness and PPI indexes for the different soil textures evaluated. PPNs population densities and diversity have been shown to be significantly affected by soil texture, with lower abundances in loam than in silt soils [49] or higher diversity in soils with higher sand content [58].
Olive cultivar has been shown as an important factor determining nematode assemblages in southern Spain [52]. In this study we confirmed this finding with a sampling of a high number of olive cultivars that were grown in commercial orchards in different geographical areas of Andalusia. Olive cultivar also had a strong influence on both, PNN abundance (P = 0.0011) and diversity estimated by the Richness and Shannon indexes (P < 0.0107) although ranking of olive varieties changed across indexes (Fig. 1D). Thus, PNN abundance was significantly highest (P < 0.05) for ‘Picudo’, ‘Picual’ and ‘Gordal’, with ‘Nevadillo’ showing the lowest (P < 0.05) (Fig. 1D). The Richness index was significantly highest (P < 0.05) in ‘Picudo’, with ‘Picual’, ‘Royal’ and ‘Arbequina’ reaching the lowest values (P < 0.05). On the other hand, the Shannon index was highest in ‘Nevadillo’ followed by ‘Acebuche’, being lower in all other olive varieties that showed similar (P≥0.05) values among them (Fig. 1D). No significant differences (P > 0.1132) occurred for the Evenness and PPI indexes due to olive cultivar (Fig. 1D). Very different responses of resistance/tolerance and susceptibility to PPNs have been described in olive cultivars for specific PPNs species [12, 16]. However, although plant root vigor and exploration ability could be an important factor determining the resistance levels for PPNs in olive varieties or cultivars, the soil physicochemical characteristics and climatic conditions where the olive orchards are established can exert a higher influence on PPN populations than the genotype itself, which should be explored.
Finally, irrigation regime and crop age did not influence statistically (P > 0.05) any of the diversity indexes tested, with the only exception of the Shannon index that was significantly higher (P = 0.0116) in irrigated olive orchards compared to that under rain-fed regime (data not shown). Our findings support previous results indicating that soil moisture may influence diversity of PPNs in a positive way [59].
Unsupervised analysis of the structure of plant-parasitic nematode populations
Unsupervised cluster analysis was performed using the Bray-Curtis dissimilarity index of PPN populations as an initial step towards inferring any structure in the PPN populations among the 92 olive orchard soils sampled. The optimum number of clusters was estimated to be four on the basis of the maximum average silhouette width obtained with K-means partitioning (Fig. 2; S1 Fig.). Olive orchards were well-clustered in their respective groups (i.e., large silhouette values), with the exception of 20 of 32 olive orchards included in cluster I that were not clearly assigned to this cluster (i.e., negative silhouette values) (S1 Fig.). Helicotylenchus spp. were the PPN genera with the highest influence in determining the olive orchard clustering (Fig. 2). Up to seven Helicotylenchus species were found being highly prevalent and abundant in the majority of the Andalusian olive orchards sampled in our study (Table 1). In all soil samples (52) from orchards in Cluster II H. digonicus showed the highest density, occasionally four samples included H. oleae and one sample included H. pseudorobustus, but specimens of the other four Helicotylenchus species were not found. Other nematode species in this cluster were less frequent and included Merlinius brevidens (41 orchards), Xiphinema pachtaicum (36 orchards), Filenchus sp. (32 orchards), and Tylenchus davainei (21 orchards). Orchards in Cluster III showed high densities of H. canadensis, Ogma rhombosquamatum, Filenchus thornei, Xiphinema pachtaicum, Merlinius brevidens and Tylenchus davainei. In contrast, soil samples from orchards included in Cluster IV showed high population levels of H. vulgaris, and other abundant species included Xiphinema pachtaicum and Aglenchus agricola. Cluster I included olive orchards showing a high diversity of nematode species and up to five species of Helicotylenchus. Other species present in high frequency in this Cluster were Filenchus sp. (23 orchards), Paratylenchus microdorus (15 orchards), Criconemoides xenoplax (15 orchards) and Tylenchus davainei (14 orchards). The influence and prevalence of Helicotylenchus species in olive orchards is notorious and species seem to be mutually excluded in the same field. Indeed, the frequency of occurrence of H. digonicus was significantly and negatively correlated (Ʈken,b < -0.2408, n = 92, P < 0.0055) with that of H. vulgaris and H. canadensis, but not with that of H. pseudorobustus (Ʈken,b = -0.1137, n = 92, P < 0.1908).
The Ward linkage method was applied to the Bray–Curtis dissimilarity matrix calculated from frequency of occurrence of the 77 species of PPNs identified among the 92 olive orchard soils sampled. The optimum number of clusters and the degree of membership of an olive orchard to each of the four clusters was estimated on the basis of the maximum average silhouette width according to K-means partitioning (S1 Fig.). The intensity of color (from light yellow to deep red) shown for each nematode species correlates with abundance Log(number of individuals/500 cm3 of soil).
Some Helicotylenchus species have been associated with root necrosis and have been shown capable to affect olive trees growth under certain growing conditions [60]. In general, Helicotylenchus spp. can adopt a semiendoparasitic feeding behavior on olive feeder roots [12] and with this strategy occupy the most viable site in the root. Although olive seems to be well adapted to these parasites, a 78% plant-growth reduction has been found on olive plants inoculated with 1,000 individuals of H. dihystera under controlled conditions experiments [61]. Sampling sites that included feral forms of olives or ‘Acebuches’ (sites 19, 31 and 32) were distributed in different clusters [cluster II (site 32) and cluster I (sites 19 and 31)]. The diversity of site 19 (with 14 species including H. dihystera) was higher than that of sites 31 and 32 with 7 and 9 species, respectively, but all of them included H. digonicus.
From the 20th most prevalent nematode species, i.e., those present in at least 10 olive orchards, some significant (P < 0.05) correlations were detected: (i) P. microdorus was positively (P < 0.05) correlated with P. thornei, C. informis, C. annuliferum, M. obscurus, and Z. guevarai; (ii) C. xenoplax was positively (P < 0.05) correlated with Filenchus sp., P. thornei and C. annuliferum; (iii) X. pachtaicum was positively (P < 0.05) correlated with O. rhombosquamatum, but negatively (P < 0.05) with M. brevidens and Ditylenchus sp. In addition, some other pairwise significant correlation occurred. In samples included in cluster II a significant and negative association (Ʈken,b < -0.2198, n = 52, P = 0.0259) of H. digonicus was found with X. pachtaicum. Xiphinema pachtaicum is a dagger nematode widely distributed in the Iberian Peninsula in undisturbed soil with not high ecological requirements [62–63]. H. digonicus and X. pachtaicum have a semiendoparasitic feeding behavior in olive feeder roots and they might compete for occupying most viable sites in the olive rhizosphere [12].
Factors shaping the distribution and diversity of plant-parasitic nematodes in olive orchards
It has been shown that although diversity indexes (such as Richness, Eveness and Shannon used in our study) and unsupervised cluster analysis are useful in describing community characteristics they do not provide information about relevant compositional features of PPNs communities taxa and the environmental factors shaping their population structure. Consequently, to specifically determine the PPN community composition and to identify hypothetical gradients likely related to the differentiation in PPN composition among the olive orchards sampled we used NMDS ordination to represent, in two dimensions, the pairwise Bray-Curtis dissimilarities between PPN frequencies (incorporating taxon abundance and identity). The projection of each of the environmental and agronomic variables independently onto the NMDS ordination (Fig. 3; Table 2) allowed to identify that within the agronomic variables PPN communities can be significantly (P < 0.05) differentiated according to soil texture and the cultivar genotype of the olive orchard, whereas not significant (P≥0.05) grouping could be found according to the orchard management system, presence of a vegetative cover, age of plantation and the irrigation regime (Table 2). Interestingly, with the exception of OMS, these later agronomic variables also did not modify abundance and diversity indexes associated to the PPN populations in the olive orchards. Thus, there was a tendency to locate olive samples in the NMDS ordination according to the olive cultivar (Fig. 3). The effect of olive genotype in soil nematode community has already been addressed above. A recent study [52] demonstrated that olive genotypes significantly influence the nematode assemblages present in their rhizospheric soil in a collection of olive cultivars growing in a single orchard and therefore under the same environmental conditions. In artificial inoculations ‘Picual’ and ‘Arbequina’ have been tested against C. xenoplax, H. digonicus, H. pseudorobustus, M. arenaria race 2, Meloidogyne incognita race 1, Meloidogyne javanica, Pratylenchus penetrans and Pratylenchus vulnus and both cultivars showed differences in reproduction factors for the two Helicotylenchus spp. [41]. Other studies have found differences between cultivars and olive rootstocks in the reproduction of Meloidogyne spp., P. vulnus and Xiphinema index, in some cases associated with inoculum levels [21, 64]. We hypothesize that several root parameters (size, numbers, softness, exudation) could affect the diversity and abundance of PPN species in the rhizospheric soil. Also, specific bacterial, fungal and mycorrhizal rhizosphere populations associated to specific olive cultivars could affect the plant attractiveness and nematode pathogenicity [8, 65–67]. This effect could be even stronger in crops with a long period of establishment in the field as it is the case for olive.
The fitted vectors of environmental variables (soil physicochemical and climatic) and the agronomic variable olive cultivar (each of the 11 olive cultivars is shown with different symbols) that were most significantly and strongly associated (P < 0.05) with the ordination and shown in Table 2 are also represented (a generalized additive model fitted contours show also maximum temperature (Tmax) ramp (ºC).
The host plant has been shown as the most important factor driving force in nematode populations, but abiotic factors are also important in maintaining the steady state [58]. PPNs composition among olive orchards was also strongly related (P<0.0330; 0.233>r2>0.077) to several environmental and agronomic characteristics comprising maximum and minimum temperature, soil texture, soil pH, and exchangeable K and sand content (Fig. 3, Table 2). Other environmental factors showing a lower effect (P < 0.051) included the C:N ratio of the soil samples (Table 2).
A multivariate regression tree was also calculated to summarize the relationships between PPN community composition and environmental and agronomic variables. This tree with the most informative variable in each split is shown in Fig. 4. The tree explained >32.5% of the variability in PPN profiles, much of which were accounted by the first split based on clay content (Fig. 4). Then, sand content was the next best predictor for the second-order splits, that allowed to differentiate two groups within soils with < 17% of clay content, one (Group I) formed by two soils with high frequencies of H. pseudorobustus and total Richness (8 PPN species) and Group II formed by 18 soils with a higher total Richness of PPNs (46 species) including the most abundant species H. digonicus. Exchangeable K allowed differentiating heavier soils (clay > 17% and sand <15%), with two groups formed by Group III with six soils and moderate Richness of PPNs (23 species) and Group IV formed by three olive orchards with lower Richness (14 species) and a high frequency of H. vulgaris. On the other hand, for the other second-order split the three unique orchards with the olive cv. ‘Gordal’ were clearly differentiated (Group VI) from the remaining orchards (Group V, 60 soils) including soils with nine olive cultivars, a high frequency of H. digonicus and high total Richness (63 species). These three olive orchards from Group VI showed a lower total Richness (17 species) but a high frequency of H. digonicus and H. canadensis (Fig. 4).
The tree was calculated using frequency of PPNs in each olive orchard. For each split a rule is selected based on the predictors to minimize the dissimilarity within the plant parasitic nematode profiles in the resulting two nodes (main rule is shown above the node). At each terminal node, the mean relative abundances of each plant parasitic nematode are shown as bar plots, together with the number of olive orchards for each group and the PPN species with the highest frequency.
Some studies have been performed in order to link crop management, soil characteristics and nematode communities [44, 48, 68–69]. Our study was carried out specifically on PPNs in a wide-region sampling area of olive orchards in Andalusia. Habitat structure is complex in soil because of a combination of physical constraints imposed by pore structure, varying soil moisture, and resource distribution (plant roots and organic debris) [45] that can interact differentially according to soils, climate, crops and geographic locations. However, available information comes from studies focused on a limited number of locations. In addition, our study is pioneer in discerning how PPNs interact specifically with the olive crop under a wide range of agronomic, climate and soil physico-chemical characteristics in a wide region in Southern Spain representative of the highest surface dedicated to olive cultivation in the world [2].
Soil type and texture have been demonstrated to have much stronger effect on PPN populations than orchard management when comparing conventional and organic farms [48] and also have strong influence in the rhizosphere microbiota of olive soils [8, 10, 26, 44]. In the same way, clay and sand content as well as average maximum and minimal annual temperatures were significantly (P < 0.05) associated with the PPN communities in this study, and could differentiate population structure of PPNs in olive orchards by their frequency of occurrence in the NMDS and MRT analyses. Abundance of PPNs has been positively related to mean annual temperatures in a global scale [42]. Sand content can influence the PPN communities, probably due to its indirect effect on soil pH and soil temperature. Sandy soils have higher thermal conductivity than soils with higher clay contents which may explain also their significant relationship with PPN assemblages [70]. Soil nematode communities have been shown to be highly influenced by soil pH in other studies [47, 69, 71] as well as exchangeable K that has been found as an important parameter for determining populations of some PPN genera [72]. Additionally, many different soil physicochemical characteristics (including the ones included in this study) have been associated specifically to some genera and to density gradients of some PPNs [72–73]. However, the effect of each soil factor varied according to the PPN species. How the physicochemical properties of the soil interact with PPNs are difficult to explain in some circumstances, as exchangeable K, pH and sand, have a direct effect on plant health, and this effect could be stronger that the direct effect on nematode populations [72], which deserves more research.
Conclusions
A healthy soil is defined as a stable system with resilience to stress, high biological diversity, and high levels of internal nutrient cycling [74]. PPNs are a major constraint for agriculture that in most cases are considered as the “unseen enemies of crops” because of the unspecific visible symptoms they cause on crops (chlorosis, less vigor, early senescence, etc.) and the difficulties of their diagnosis [75]. This work has studied for the first time the population density, structure and diversity of PPNs infecting olive in a wide-region in southern Spain that included 92 locations. Our study allowed determining which agronomic or environmental factors associated to the olive orchards are the main drivers of the PPN population density and structure. Some soil physicochemical factors (texture, pH, sand and clay, and extractable K), climatic variables (minimum and maximum temperatures) and the agronomic variable olive cultivar were the factors driving the PPN population levels and community structure. Although it was restricted to a specific nematode trophic group (i.e., the plant-parasitic nematodes), this study could be of help to choose the most appropriate olive cultivar for the establishment of new plantations. This will need to take into consideration the susceptibility level of those cultivars to the PPNs present in the specific soils and environments where the plantations will be established.
Supporting Information
S1 Table. Geographic coordinates, orchard management system, soil management, olive cultivar, abundance, Richness, Shannon, and Evenness diversity indexes and Plant-Parasitic Index (PPI) of the 92 olive orchards sampled.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0116890.s001
(PDF)
S1 Fig. Silhouette plot calculated using K-means partitioning showing the silhouette width for each individual sample.
The number of clusters was estimated as that giving the largest average silhouette width for the 92 orchards plots.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0116890.s002
(TIF)
Acknowledgments
We thank F.J. Durán Gutiérrez, C. Cantalapiedra-Navarrete, and J. Martín-Barbarroja for the excellent technical assistance.
Author Contributions
Conceived and designed the experiments: BBL MMB PC. Performed the experiments: PC MMB BBL JEPR. Analyzed the data: BBL JANC. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: BBL PC. Wrote the paper: BBL PC JEPR JANC MMB.
References
- 1.
MAGRAMA (2014) Estadísticas agrarias (Agricultural Statistics for Spain). Ministerio de Agricultura, Alimentación y Medio Ambiente. Available: http://www.magrama.gob.es/es/estadistica/temas/estadisticas-agrarias/agricultura/. Accessed 2014 Dec 18.
- 2.
International Olive Council (IOC) (2014) World and European Union olive oil figures. Available: http://www.internationaloliveoil.org/estaticos/view/131-world-olive-oil-figures. Accessed 2014 Dec 18.
- 3.
FAOSTAT (2014) Available: http://faostat.fao.org/site/567/DesktopDefault.aspx?PageID=567#ancor. Accessed 2014 Dec 18.
- 4.
CAP-JA (2014) Estadísticas agrarias (Agricultural statistics for Andalusia, Spain). Consejería de Agricultura y Pesca, Junta de Andalucía, Sevilla, Spain. Available: http://www.juntadeandalucia.es/agriculturaypesca/portal/servicios/estadisticas/estadisticas/agrarias/superficies-y-producciones.html. Accessed 2014 Dec 18.
- 5.
CAP-JA (2003) Consejería de Agricultura y Pesca. El olivar andaluz. Junta de Andalucía, Sevilla, Spain. El olivar andaluz. Servicio de Publicaciones y Divulgación, Available: http://www.juntadeandalucia.es/agriculturaypesca/prospectiva. Accessed 2014 Dec 18.
- 6. Milgroom J, Soriano MA, Garrido JM, Gómez JA, Fereres E (2007) The influence of a shift from conventional to organic olive farming on soil management and erosion risk in Southern Spain. Renew Agric Food Syst 22: 1–10.
- 7. Gómez JA, Amato M, Celano G, Koubouris GC (2008) Organic olive orchards on sloping land: More than a specialty niche production system? J Environ Manage 89: 99–109. pmid:17905510
- 8. Landa BB, Aranda S, Montes-Borrego M, Soriano MA, Gómez JA, et al. (2014) Soil factors involved in the diversity and structure of soil bacterial communities in commercial organic olive orchards in Southern Spain. Environ Microbiol Rep 6: 196–207. pmid:24596294
- 9. Lodolini EM, Neri D, Gangatharan R. Ponzio C (2013) Organic olive farming. Afr J Agric Res 8: 6426–6434.
- 10. Montes-Borrego M, Navas-Cortés JA, Landa BB (2013) Linking microbial functional diversity of olive rhizosphere soil to management systems in commercial orchards in southern Spain. Agr Ecosyst Environ 181: 169–178.
- 11. Soriano MA, Álvarez S, Landa BB, Gómez JA (2012) Soil properties in organic olive orchads following different weed management in a rolling landscape of Andalusia, Spain. Renew Agr Food Syst 29: 83–91.
- 12. Castillo P, Nico A, Navas-Cortés JA, Landa BB, Jiménez-Díaz RM, et al. (2010) Plant-parasitic nematodes attacking olive trees and their management. Plant Dis 94: 148–162.
- 13. Koenning SR, Overstreet C, Noling JW, Donald PA, Becker JO, et al. (1999) Survey of crop losses in response to phytoparasitic nematodes in the United States for 1994. J Nematol 31: 587–618. pmid:19270925
- 14. Pérez BA, Barreto D, Docampo D, Otero L, Costilla M, et al. (2001) Current status of the drying syndrome (seca) of olive trees in Argentina (Abstr.). Phytopathology 91: S71.
- 15.
Karssen G, Moens M (2006) Root-knot nematodes. In: Plant Nematology. Perry RN & Moens M, eds. CABI, Wallinford, UK. Pp: 59–90.
- 16. Ali N, Chapuis E, Tavoillot J, Mateille T (2014) Plant-parasitic nematodes associated with olive tree (Olea europaea L.) with a focus on the Mediterranean Basin: A review. C R Biol 337: 423–442. pmid:25103828
- 17. Lamberti F, Vovlas N (1993) Plant parasitic nematodes associated with olive. Bulletin OEPP/EPPO 23: 481–488.
- 18. Nico AI, Rapoport HF, Jiménez-Díaz RM, Castillo P (2002) Incidence and population density of plant-parasitic nematodes associated with olive planting stocks at nurseries in southern Spain. Plant Dis 86: 1075–1079.
- 19. Castillo P, Vovlas N (2002) Factors affecting egg hatch of Heterodera mediterranea and differential responses of olive cultivars to infestation. J Nematol 34: 146–150. pmid:19265924
- 20.
McKenry MV (1994) Nematodes of Olive. In: Olive Production Manual. Ferguson L, Sibett GS, Martin GC (Eds.). University of California, Publ. 3353, Oakland, pp. 97–99.
- 21.
Sasanelli N (2009) Olive nematodes and their control. In: Integrated Management of Fruit Crops and Forest Nematodes. Ciancio A, Mukerji G (Eds). pp. 275–315.
- 22. Hashim Z (1982) Distribution, pathogenicity and control of nematodes associated with olive. Rev Nématol 5: 169–181.
- 23. Bongers T, Ferris H (1999) Nematode community structure as a bioindicator in environmental monitoring. Trends Ecol Evol 14: 224–228. pmid:10354624
- 24. Freckman DW, Ettema CH (1993) Assessing nematode communities in agroecosystems of varying human intervention, Agric Ecosyst Environ 45: 239–261.
- 25. Bongers T, Van Der Meulen H, Korthals G (1997) Inverse relationship between the nematode maturity index and plant parasite index under enriched nutrient conditions. Appl Soil Ecol 6: 195–199.
- 26. Montes-Borrego M, Metsis M, Landa BB (2014) Arbuscular mycorhizal fungi associated with the olive crop across the Andalusian landscape: factors driving community differentiation. PLoS ONE 9: e96397. pmid:24797669
- 27.
Coolen WA (1979) Methods for extraction of Meloidogyne spp. and other nematodes from roots and soil. In: Root-knot nematodes (Meloidogyne species). Systematics, biology and control. Lamberti F., Taylor C.E. (Editors), Academic Press, New York, USA, pp. 317–329.
- 28. Seinhorst JW (1962) On the killing, fixation and transferring to glycerine of the nematodes. Nematologica 8: 29–32.
- 29.
Oksanen J, Blanchet FG, Kindt R, Legendre P, O’Hara RG, et al. (2011) Vegan: community ecology package. R package version 1.17–6. Available: http://CRAN.R-project.org/package=vegan. Accessed 2014 Dec 18.
- 30. Bongers T (1990) The maturity index: An ecological measure of environmental disturbance based on nematode species composition. Oecologia 83: 14–19.
- 31. Elliott AC, Hynan LS (2011) A SAS macro implementation of a multiple comparison post hoc test for a Kruskal–Wallis analysis. Comput Meth Prog Bio 102: 75–80.
- 32.
Maechler M, Rousseeuw P, Struyf A, Hubert M, Hornik K (2014) cluster: Cluster Analysis Basics and Extensions. An R Library. Available: http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/cluster/.http://CRAN.R-project.org/package=vegan.
- 33. De’ath G (2002) Multivariate regression trees: a new technique for modelling species—environment relationships. Ecology 83: 1105–1117.
- 34.
Peña-Santiago R, Castillo P, Escuer M, Guerrero P, Talavera M, et al. (2004) Tylenchid species (Nematoda, Tylenchida) recorded in the Iberian Peninsula and the Balearic Islands: A Compendium. Jaén: Servicio de Publicaciones, Universidad de Jaén, Spain. 127 pp.
- 35. Yeates Gw, Bongers T, De Goede RGM, Freckman DW, Georgieva SS (1993) Feeding habits in soil nematode families and genera-An outline for soil ecologists. J. Nematol. 25: 315–331. pmid:19279775
- 36. Castillo P, Vovlas N, Nico A, Jiménez-Díaz RM (1999) Infection of olive trees by Heterodera mediterranea in orchards in southern Spain. Plant Dis 83: 710–713.
- 37. Vovlas N, Inserra RN (1983) Biology of Heterodera mediterranea. J. Nematol, 15: 571–576. pmid:19295850
- 38.
Davis EE, Venette RC (2004) Mini Risk Assessment British root-knot nematode: Meloidogyne artiellia Franklin [Nematoda: Meloidogynidae]. Cooperative Agricultural Pest Survey Program Pest Risk Assessement.
- 39. Lamberti F, Baines RC (1969). Effect of Pratylenchus vulnus on the growth of “Ascolano” and “Manzanillo” olive trees in a glasshouse. Plant Dis Rep 53: 557–558.
- 40. Lamberti F, Ciccarese F, Sasanelli N, Ambrico A, D’Addabbo T, et al. (2001) Relationships between plant parasitic nematodes and Verticillium dahliae on olive. Nematol Mediterr 29: 3–9.
- 41. Nico AI, Jiménez-Díaz RM, Castillo P (2003) Host suitability of the olive cultivars Arbequina and Picual for plant-parasitic nematodes. J Nematol 35: 29–34. pmid:19265971
- 42. Palomares-Rius JE, Guesmi I, Horrigue-Raouani N, Cantalapiedra-Navarrete C, Liébanas G, et al. (2014) Morphological and molecular characterisation of Pratylenchus oleae n. sp. (Nematoda: Pratylenchidae) parasitizing wild and cultivated olives in Spain and Tunisia. Eur J Plant Pathol 140: 53–67.
- 43. Nielsen UN, Ayres E, Wall DH, Li G, Bardgett RD, et al. (2014) Global-scale patterns of soil nematode assemblage structure in relation to climate and ecosystem properties. Global Ecol. Biogeogr 23: 968–978.
- 44. García-Ruiz R, Ochoa V, Viñegla B, Hinojosa MB, Peña-Santiago R, et al. (2009) Soil enzymes, nematode community and selected physico-chemical properties as soil quality indicators in organic and conventional olive oil farming: Influence of seasonality and site features. Appl Soil Ecol 41: 305–314.
- 45. Neher DA (2010) Ecology of plant and free-living nematodes in natural and agricultural soil. Ann Rev Phytopathol 48: 371–394.
- 46. Coll P, Le Cadre E, Villenave C (2012) How are nematode communities affected during a conversion from conventional to organic farming in southern French vineyards?. Nematology 14: 665–676.
- 47. Neher DA (1999) Nematode communities in organically and conventionally managed agricultural soils. J Nematol 31: 142–154. pmid:19270884
- 48. Van Diepeningen AD, de Vos OJ, Korthals GW, van Bruggen AHC (2006) Effects of organic versus conventional management on chemical and biological parameters in agricultural soils. Appl Soil Ecol 31: 120–135.
- 49. Yeates GW, Bardgett RD, Cook R, Hobbs PJ, Bowling PJ, et al. (1997). Faunal and microbial diversity in three Welsh grassland soils under conventional and organic management regimes. J Appl Ecol 34: 453–470.
- 50. Briar SS, Grewal PS, Somasekhar N, Stinner D, Miller SA (2007) Soil nematode community, organic matter, microbial biomass and nitrogen dynamics in field plots transitioning from conventional to organic management. Appl Soil Ecol 37: 256–266.
- 51. Wardle DA, Yeates GW, Watson RN, Nicholson KS (1995) Impacts of disturbance on detritus food-webs in agroecosystems of contrasting tillage and weed management strategies. Adv Ecol Res 26: 105–185.
- 52. Palomares-Rius JE, Castillo P, Montes-Borrego M, Müller H, Landa BB (2012) Nematode community populations in the rhizosphere of cultivated olive differs according to the plant genotype. Soil Biol Biochem 45: 168–171.
- 53. Stirling GR, Halpin NV, Bell MJ, Moody PW (2010) Impact of tillage and residues from rotation crops on the nematode community in soil and surface mulch during the following sugarcane crop. Proc Aust Soc Sugar Cane Technol 32: 152–168.
- 54. DuPont ST, Ferris H, Van Horn M (2009) Effects of cover crop quality and quantity on nematode-based soil food webs and nutrient cycling. Appl Soil Ecol 41: 157–167.
- 55. Parmelee RW, Alston DG (1986) Nematode trophic structure in conventional and no-tillage agroecosystems. J Nematol 18: 403–407. pmid:19294199
- 56. Zhang X, Li Q, Zhu A, Liang W, Zhang J, et al. (2012) Effects of tillage and residue management on soil nematode communities in North China. Ecol Indic 13: 75–81.
- 57. Kruger DHM, Fourie JC, Malan AP (2013) Cover crops with biofumigation properties for the suppression of plant-parasitic nematodes: A review. S Afr J Enol Vitic 34: 287–295.
- 58. Norton DC (1989) Abiotic soil factors and plant-parasitic nematode communities. J Nematol 21: 299–307. pmid:19287613
- 59. Todd TC, Blair JM, Milliken GA (1999). Effects of altered soil water availability on a tall grass prairie nematode community. Appl Soil Ecol 13: 45–55.
- 60. Inserra RN, Vovlas N, Morgan Golden A (1979) Helicotylenchus oleae n. sp. and H. neopaxilli n. sp. (Hoplolaimidae), two new spiral nematodes parasitic on olive trees in Italy. J Nematol 11: 56–62. pmid:19305529
- 61. Diab K, El-Eraki S (1968) Plant-parasitic nematodes associated with olive decline in the United Arab Republic. Plant Dis Rep 52: 150–154.
- 62. Brown DJF, Halbrendt JM, Jonez AT, Taylor CE, Lamberti F (1994) An appraisal of some aspects of the ecology of nematode vectors of plant viruses. Nematol Mediterr 22: 253–263.
- 63. Navas A, Bello A, Arias M (1988) Ecology and potential distribution of Xiphinema diversicaudatum and X. pachtaicum (Nematoda: Longidoridae) in continental Spain. Nematologica 34: 314–330.
- 64. Jahanshahi Afshar F, Sasanelli N, Hosseininejad SA, Tanha Maafi Z (2014) Effects of the root-knot nematodes Meloidogyne incognita and M. javanica on olive plants growth in glasshouse conditions. Helminthologia 51: 46–52.
- 65. Castillo P, Nico AI, Azcón-Aguilar C, Del Río Rincón C, Calvet C, et al. (2006) Protection of olive planting stocks against parasitism of root-knot nematodes by arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi. Plant Pathol 55: 705–713.
- 66.
Khodakaramian N, Khodakaramian G (2012) Diminish of olive root knot nematode damage using safe environmental rhizobacteria. International Conference on Eco-systems and Biological Sciences (ICEBS’2012) Penang (Malaysia) May 19–20, pages 51–54.
- 67. Siddiqui IA, Shaukat SS (2003) Endophytic bacteria: prospects and opportunities for the biological control of plant-parasitic nematodes. Nematol medit 31: 111–120.
- 68. Ugarte CM, Zaborski ER, Wander MM (2013) Nematode indicators as integrative measures of soil condition in organic cropping systems. Soil Biol Biochem 64: 103–113.
- 69. Wang KH, McSorley R, Gallaher RN (2004) Relationship of soil management history and nutrient status to nematode community structure. Nematropica 34: 83–95.
- 70.
Gardner CMK, Laryea KB, Unger PW (1999) Other physical constraints to soil productivity. In: Soil physical constraints to plant growth and crop production, Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, Rome, Italy, pp. 51–64.
- 71. Mulder CH, De Zwart D, Van Wijnen HJ, Schouten AJ, Breure AM (2003) Observational and simulated evidence of ecological shifts within the soil nematode community of agroecosystems under conventional and organic farming. Funct Ecol 17: 516–525.
- 72. Wallace MK, Rust RH, Hawkins DM, Macdonald DH (1993) Correlation of edaphic factors with plant-parasitic nematode population densities in a forage field. J Nematol 25: 642–653. pmid:19279821
- 73. Chen SY, Sheaffer CC, Wyse DL, Nickel P, Kandel H (2012) Plant-parasitic nematode communities and their associations with soil factors in organically farmed fields in Minnesota. J Nematol 44: 361–369. pmid:23482641
- 74. Van Bruggen AHC, Semenov AM (2000) In search of biological indicators for soil health and disease suppression. Appl Soil Ecol 15: 13–24.
- 75.
Ferris JM, Ferris VR (1998) Biology of plant-parasitic nematodes. In: Plant and Nematode interactions. Barker KR Pederson GA &Windham GL (Editors). Numer 36 series Agronomy. American Society of Agronomy, Crop Science Society of America and Soil Science Society of America publishers, Madison, Wisconsin, USA. Pp: 21–36.