Figures
Abstract
Infectious diseases and fish feeds management are probably the major expenses in the aquaculture business. Hence, it is a priority to define sustainable strategies which simultaneously avoid therapeutic procedures and reinforce fish immunity. Currently, one preferred approach is the use of immunostimulants which can be supplemented to the fish diets. Arginine is a versatile amino acid with important mechanisms closely related to the immune response. Aiming at finding out how arginine affects the innate immune status or improve disease resistance of European seabass (Dicentrarchus labrax) against vibriosis, fish were fed two arginine-supplemented diets (1% and 2% arginine supplementation). A third diet meeting arginine requirement level for seabass served as control diet. Following 15 or 29 days of feeding, fish were sampled for blood, spleen and gut to assess cell-mediated immune parameters and immune-related gene expression. At the same time, fish from each dietary group were challenged against Vibrio anguillarum and survival was monitored. Cell-mediated immune parameters such as the extracellular superoxide and nitric oxide decreased in fish fed arginine-supplemented diets. Interleukins and immune-cell marker transcripts were down-regulated by the highest supplementation level. Disease resistance data were in accordance with a generally depressed immune status, with increased susceptibility to vibriosis in fish fed arginine supplemented diets. Altogether, these results suggest a general inhibitory effect of arginine on the immune defences and disease resistance of European seabass. Still, further research will certainly clarify arginine immunomodulation pathways thereby allowing the validation of its potential as a prophylactic strategy.
Citation: Azeredo R, Pérez-Sánchez J, Sitjà-Bobadilla A, Fouz B, Tort L, Aragão C, et al. (2015) European Sea Bass (Dicentrarchus labrax) Immune Status and Disease Resistance Are Impaired by Arginine Dietary Supplementation. PLoS ONE 10(10): e0139967. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0139967
Editor: Daniel Merrifield, The University of Plymouth, UNITED KINGDOM
Received: July 2, 2015; Accepted: September 18, 2015; Published: October 8, 2015
Copyright: © 2015 Azeredo et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the paper and its Supporting Information files.
Funding: This work was partially funded by European Union’s Seventh Framework Programme AQUAEXCEL (Aquaculture Infrastructures for Excellence in European Fish Research, grant agreement no. 262336), AQUAIMPROV (reference NORTE-07-0124-FEDER-000038), PEst-C/MAR/LA0015/2013 and UID/Multi/04423/2013. It was co-financed by the North Portugal Regional Operational Programme (ON.2 - O Novo Norte), under the National Strategic Reference Framework, through the European Regional Development Fund, and through the COMPETE - Operational Competitiveness Programme and national funds through the Fundação para a Ciência e Tecnologia, respectively. RA and BC were supported by Fundação para a Ciência e Tecnologia (grants SFRH/BD/89457/2012 and SFRH/BPD/77210/2011, respectively). Additional funding was obtained from the Generalitat Valenciana through the project REVIDPAQUA (ISIC/2012/003).
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Introduction
The biggest challenges regarding European sea bass (Dicentrarchus labrax) Mediterranean aquaculture are the severe bacterial outbreaks occurring throughout the year [1]. Among them, vibriosis causes the highest mortality rates and, consequently, great economic losses. Vibrio anguillarum is the main aetiological agent of vibriosis often leading to a septicaemia as well as haemorrhages and exophthalmia [2]. Immunization by vaccination has been applied [3], but distinct and complementary approaches are recommended in order to successfully and cost-efficiently produce European sea bass. Indeed, formulation of fish feeds must address other issues concerning fish welfare and health besides promoting optimum growth. Supplementing fish diets with key ingredients is a strategy often used in aquaculture to improve a selected trait. Such diets (functional diets) can also be used to improve fish defences and thereby, avoid high mortalities during a viral or bacterial incursion episode. Vitamins, prebiotics, probiotics and pigments such as xanthophylls and astaxanthins have been utilized as supplements for these diets [4–6]. More recently, amino acids (AA) have been employed in studies of immunomodulation [7–9], but such knowledge is still scarce.
Arginine is one of the most versatile AA, hence it represents a good candidate for inclusion in functional diets. Arginine requirements among different fish species are generally high given its great contribution to proteins composition and body fluids and also the almost total absence of its de novo synthesis, as this is an essential AA [10]. Similarly to higher vertebrates, fish can produce nitric oxide (NO) and ornithine from arginine using the enzymes inducible nitric oxide synthase (iNOS) and arginase, respectively [11]. When produced by phagocytes, NO is used against pathogens, acting as an oxidant that compromises structures integrity and function. Such actions represent self-damage as well, and when combined with superoxide anion, the toxicity dangerously increases [12]. Furthermore, arginine can enhance cell proliferation by fuelling polyamine biosynthesis through provision of ornithine [13]. Altogether, upon infection, these metabolic pathways may stimulate the inflammatory response. However, arginine can also mediate immunosuppressive mechanisms. In mammals, T-cell activation and function is dictated by arginine metabolism in myeloid suppressor cells (MSC) [11]. These cells metabolize arginine with either arginase or iNOS according to different stimuli and the derived products are directly involved in the suppression of T-cell functions. When arginine was added both to a primary enterocyte culture media or to the diet of Jian carp (Cyprinus carpio var. Jian), an inhibition of the LPS-induced inflammatory response was detected [14].
While being aware of the high importance of arginine as an essential constituent for growth, it would be of major interest to fully determine the mechanisms of arginine immunomodulation. Therefore, this study aims to decipher to what extent dietary arginine supplementation may modulate the European sea bass immune response and disease resistance against Vibrio anguillarum.
Material and Methods
2.1 Diet formulation
Three plant protein-based diets with a reduced inclusion level of fish meal and fish soluble protein concentrates (12.2%) were formulated and manufactured by Sparos Lda. (Olhão, Portugal). A blend of fish oil (6.2%): rapeseed oil (4.2%): palm oil (4.2%) was used as dietary lipid source. The control diet (CTRL) was formulated to include an indispensable AA concentration meeting the ideal pattern estimated for European sea bass [15]. The two other diets were identical to the CTRL but supplemented with L-arginine at 1% or 2% (Arg1 and Arg2, respectively) at the expenses of wheat gluten. Main ingredients were ground (below 250 μm) in a micropulverizer hammer mill (SH1; Hosokawa Micron, B.V., Doetinchem, The Netherlands). Powder ingredients and oils were then mixed according to the target formulation in a paddle mixer (RM90; Mainca, S.L., Granollers, Spain). All diets were manufactured by temperature-controlled extrusion (pellet sizes: 1.5 and 2 mm) by means of a low-shear extruder (P55; Italplast, S.r.l., Parma, Italy). Upon extrusion, all feed batches were dried in a convection oven (OP 750-UF; LTE Scientifics, Oldham, UK) for 4h at 45°C. Formulation and proximate composition of experimental diets are presented in Table 1.
Diets were analysed for total amino acid content. Diet samples were hydrolysed in 6M HCl at 116°C for 2 h in nitrogen-flushed glass vials. Samples were then pre-column derivatised with Waters AccQ Fluor Reagent (6-aminoquinolyl-N-hydroxysuccinimidyl carbamate) using the AccQ Tag method (Waters, USA). Analyses were done by ultra-high-performance liquid chromatography (UPLC) in a Waters reversed-phase amino acid analysis system, using norvaline as an internal standard. During acid hydrolysis asparagine is converted to aspartate and glutamine to glutamate, so the reported values for these amino acids (Asx and Glx) represent the sum of the respective amine and acid. Tryptophan was not determined, since it is partially destroyed by acid hydrolysis. The resultant peaks were analysed with EMPOWER software (Waters, USA). The AA profile of the experimental diets is presented in Table 2.
Trp was not analysed. Values are means ± SD.
2.2 Fish
All trials were carried out at the indoor experimental facilities of the Instituto de Acuicultura Torre de la Sal (IATS-CSIC, Castellón, Spain). Non vaccinated fingerlings of 0.6 g initial body weight were purchased from a commercial hatchery (Grupo Tinamenor, Santander, Spain) and acclimatized for more than two months to IATS experimental facilities. Fish were fed over the course of this period (March-June 2014) with the CTRL diet in a flow-through system with aerated seawater under natural photoperiod (12 h light/ 12 h dark) and temperature (22.95°C ± 0.9) at IATS-CSIC latitude (40°5N; 0°10E). Water parameters were daily monitored with oxygen levels always higher than 85% saturation and unionized ammonia below toxic levels (< 0.05 mg l-1).
2.3 Feeding trial and sampling
One hundred and fifty fish of 12.17 ± 0.17 g average weight were randomly distributed into six 500 l tanks. Dietary treatments were randomly assigned to duplicate groups and fish were fed to visual satiety two times per day, 6 days per week) for 15 or 29 days. At the end of these two periods, 5 fish per tank (n = 10 per diet) were euthanized by overexposure to the anaesthetic MS-222 (Sigma, Saint Louis, USA). Specimens were weighed and blood was collected from the caudal vein with heparinized syringes. An aliquot of fresh blood was used for the respiratory burst assay and the remaining blood was centrifuged at 3000 × g for 20 min at 4°C to obtain plasma. Total visceral, mesenteric fat and liver weight were recorded. Subsequently, pieces of spleen, anterior (AI) and posterior (PI) intestine were immediately taken and frozen in liquid nitrogen. Plasma and tissue samples were kept at -80°C until further analyses. All procedures were approved by the Ethics and Animal Welfare Committee of Institute of Aquaculture Torre de la Sal and carried out in a registered installation (code 36271-42-A) in accordance with the principles published in the European animal directive (2010/63/EU) and Spanish laws (Royal Decree RD53/2013) for the protection of animals used in scientific experiments. In all lethal samplings, fish were decapitated after 3-aminobenzoic acid ethyl ester (MS-222, 100 μg ml-1) over-exposure, and all efforts were made to minimize suffering.
2.4 Bacterial inoculum preparation and challenge dose validation
Vibrio anguillarum serotype O1 (strain Lab 1), isolated from diseased European sea bass was cultured in tryptic soy agar (TSA, Pronadisa, Madrid, Spain) supplemented with NaCl at a final concentration of 1% (TSA-1) at 24°C for 24 hours.
Eight different doses were tested in a pre-challenge experiment in order to validate a suitable infective dose for the bacterial challenge. Juvenile European sea bass, held in 90 l tanks at an average temperature of 22.3°C, were intracoelomically (i.c.) injected with 0.1 ml of bacterial suspensions in phosphate-buffered saline (PBS, pH 7.4) ranging from 4.7 × 103 to 1 × 106 colony forming units (CFU) ml-1 (8–10 fish/dose) [16]. Negative control fish received 0.1 ml of PBS. Mortalities were monitored for 8 days and were considered due to V. anguillarum only if the inoculated bacterium was recovered in pure culture from internal organs. Kidney and liver samples collected from moribund fish were directly streaked onto TSA-1 plates. For identification of the pathogen, a slide agglutination test with the corresponding antiplasma was used. The dose producing mortalities between 40 and 50% (LD40-50) was chosen for the bacterial challenges.
2.5 Bacterial challenge
At the end of the first feeding period (15 days), 40 fish per dietary treatment were lightly anesthetized with clove oil (1:10,000), i.c challenged with the previously determined dose of V. anguillarum and distributed in triplicate 90 l tanks (n = 10). A group of 10 fish per dietary treatment was injected with PBS, as a control of the experimental handling. Fish were fed the same diets along the post-challenge period. The second bacterial challenge was performed 29 days after the beginning of the feeding trial, following the same procedure as in the first challenge. In both challenges, mortalities were monitored daily (every two hours) until no more mortalities were observed for a minimum of two consecutive days, so the trial was terminated 8 days post-challenge. Fish showing signs of disease (fish near the water surface, slowly swimming around the air stone or motionless at the bottom of the tank) were humanely sacrificed by overexposure to the anaesthetic as previously mentioned. Post-mortem examination was performed as described above.
2.6 Respiratory burst of circulating leucocytes
The respiratory burst was assessed in circulating leucocytes at the end of each feeding period following the method described by Nikoskelainen et al. [17]. Briefly, 4 μl of fresh blood were added to 96 μl of HBSS (Hanks’ Balanced Salt Solution, pH 7.4) in a white flat-bottomed 96-well plate and incubated with 100 μl of a freshly prepared luminol suspension (2 mM luminol in 0.2 M borate buffer pH 9.0, with 2 μg ml-1 PMA) for 1 h at 24–25°C. Each sample was run in duplicate and read against a blank into which no blood was added. Luminol-amplified chemiluminescence was measured every 3 min in a plate luminescence reader (TECAN) for generation of kinetic curves. Each sample was run in duplicate and the integral luminescence in relative light units (RLU) was calculated.
2.7 Innate humoral parameters
Plasma bactericidal activity was measured according to Graham et al. [18] with some modifications [19]. A suspension of Photobacterium damselae subsp. piscicida (20 μl, 1 × 106 CFU ml-1) was added to 20 μl of plasma in duplicate wells of a U-shaped 96-well plate. HBSS was added instead of plasma to serve as positive control. After an incubation period of 2.5 h at 25°C, 25 μl of 3-(4,5 dimethyl-2-yl)-2,5-diphenyl tetrazolium bromide (1 mg ml-1, Sigma) were added to each well and plates were incubated for more 10 minutes at 25°C. Then, 200 μl of dimethyl sulfoxide (Sigma) were added after centrifugation at 2000 × g for 10 min. The absorbance of the formed, resuspended formazan was read at 560 nm in a Synergy HT (Biotek) microplate reader. Total bactericidal activity is expressed as the percentage of killed bacteria, calculated from the difference between the samples and the positive control (100% living bacteria).
Total plasma nitrite and nitrate content was measured using a Nitrate/Nitrite colorimetric kit (Roche Diagnostics GmbH, Mannheim, Germany) by adapting it to a 96-well plate and by following manufacturer’s instructions. Since both these compounds are derivatives of endogenously produced NO, they are indicative of NO amount in plasma. Briefly, 100 μl of plasma were added in duplicate to 50 μl of reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate (NADPH) followed by the addition of 4 μl of nitrate reductase. A blank was produced by adding distilled water instead of plasma. Absorbance at 540 nm was read after 30 min incubation at 25°C. Afterwards, 50 μl of sulfanilamide and an equal volume of N-(1-naphthyl)-ethylenediamine dihydrochloride were added to each well. The mixture was allowed to stand at 25°C for 15 min and absorbance was read at 540 nm. Total nitrite levels were calculated from a previously prepared sodium nitrite standard curve.
2.8 Gene expression analysis
Spleen, AI and PI were taken from fish fed the experimental diets for 29 days. Total RNA was extracted using a MagMAX™-96 total RNA isolation kit (Life Technologies, Carlsbad, CA, USA). RNA yield was 50–100 μg with 260 and 280 nm UV absorbance ratios (A260/280) of 1.9–2.1. Reverse transcription (RT) of 500 ng total RNA was performed with random decamers using a High-Capacity cDNA Reverse Transcription Kit (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA, USA) according to manufacturer’s instructions. Negative control reactions were run without reverse transcriptase and real-time quantitative PCR was carried out on a CFX96 Connect™ Real-Time PCR Detection System (Bio-Rad, Hercules, CA, USA) using a 96-well PCR array layout designed for simultaneously profiling a panel of 30 genes under uniform cycling conditions. Genes were selected for their involvement in immune response and arginine metabolism (Table 3). Among the 30 genes, 24 genes were novel for European sea bass and their sequences, derived from the IATS-Nutrigroup transcriptomic database (www.nutrigroup-iats.org/seabassdb), were uploaded to GenBank (KM225766-KM225790, S1 Table). Controls of general PCR performance were included on each array, being performed all the pipetting operations by means of the EpMotion 5070 Liquid Handling Robot (Eppendorf, Hamburg, Germany). Briefly, RT reactions were diluted to convenient concentrations and the equivalent of 660 pg of total input RNA was used in a 25 μL volume for each PCR reaction. PCR-wells contained a 2× SYBR Green Master Mix (Bio-Rad) and specific primers at a final concentration of 0.9 μM were used to obtain amplicons of 50–150 bp in length (S2 Table).
The program used for PCR amplification included an initial denaturation step at 95°C for 3 min, followed by 40 cycles of denaturation for 15 s at 95°C and annealing/extension for 60 s at 60°C. The efficiency of PCR reactions was always higher than 90%, and negative controls without sample templates were routinely performed for each primer set. The specificity of reactions was verified by analysis of melting curves (ramping rates of 0.5°C/10 s over a temperature range of 55–95°C), and linearity of serial dilutions of RT reactions. Fluorescence data acquired during the PCR extension phase were normalized using the delta–delta Ct method (Livak and Schmittgen, 2001). Β-Actin was tested for gene expression stability using GeNorm software (M score = 0.21) and it was used as housekeeping gene in the normalization procedure. Fold-change calculations were done in reference to the expression ratio between Arg1 or Arg2 and CTRL fish (values >1 indicate up-regulated genes in Arg1 or Arg2 fish; values <1 indicate down-regulated genes in Arg1 or Arg2 fish). For comparing the mRNA gene expression level of a panel of genes in a given dietary treatment, all data values were in reference to the expression level of interleukin 10 in CTRL fish, which was arbitrarily assigned a value of 1.
2.9 Statistical Analysis
Results are expressed as means ± standard error of the mean (SEM). Data were analysed for normality and homogeneity of variances and, when necessary, transformed before being treated statistically. Analysis of fish performance, respiratory burst, plasma bactericidal capacity and NO content were performed by two-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) with dietary treatment and time of sampling as main variables, whereas gene expression data were analysed by one-way ANOVA with dietary treatment as the sole variable. Whenever significant differences were found, a multiple-comparisons Tukey HSD test was performed to identify significantly different groups. For every test, the level of significance chosen was P < 0.05. All data were analysed with STATISTICA (StatSoft, Inc. 2013, version 12) for WINDOWS.
Results
3.1 Fish performance
Final fish weight was higher in fish reared for 29 days compared to those sampled at 15 days, regardless of the dietary treatment (Table 4). By contrast, the viscerosomatic index (VSI) was significantly lower in individuals fed Arg2 compared to fish fed Arg1 at day 15, whereas an increase in VSI was observed in animals fed Arg2 from day 15 to 29. Regarding the specific growth rate (SGR) and the feed conversion rate (FCR) no differences were observed among dietary treatments. Due to technical constraints, FCR data from 15 days are not presented.
Values are means ± SEM (n = 10)
3.2 Bacterial challenge
Mortality started two days after bacterial challenge, regardless of the dietary treatment or the feeding time (Fig 1a and 1b). No mortality was observed in fish injected with PBS (data not shown). Concerning the first challenge (day 15 of feeding trial), the infective dose, which was based on the pre-challenge trial, was around 1.5 ×104 CFU ml-1. The highest death numbers occurred in Arg1 and Arg2 dietary groups with 86.7% and 93.3% of mortality, respectively (Fig 1a). High mortalities, though lower, were recorded in the CTRL group (76.7%). As mortality was higher than expected in the CTRL group (probably due to an increase in mean water temperature—from initial temperature 22.3°C to final temperature 23.6°C), a lower dose was used for the second bacterial challenge (day 29 of feeding). Fish were injected with 3 × 103 CFU ml-1 and mortality was lower than in the first challenge (Fig 1b). Fish fed Arg1 and Arg2 diets were more susceptible to the infection compared to those fed the CTRL diet, showing mortalities of 67.5%, 77.5% and 52.5%, respectively.
Values are means of triplicate tanks (n = 30). SEM and sham injected fish are not presented for the clarity of the graphs.
3.3 Respiratory burst of circulating leucocytes
Dietary arginine significantly decreased the respiratory burst of circulating leucocytes, regardless of the supplementation level, when fish were fed for 29 days (Fig 2). Furthermore, the response of fish fed the Arg2 diet was also lower when fed only 15 days. An interaction between time and dietary treatment was also observed in fish fed Arg1 and Arg2 diets compared to individuals fed the CTRL diet at day 29.
Values represent means ± SEM of relative light units (n = 6). Different capital letters stand for statistically significant differences between diets regardless of feeding time. Different low case letters stand for statistically significant differences between diets within the same feeding time (Two-way ANOVA; P < 0.05)
3.4 Innate humoral parameters
No dietary effects were observed on total plasma bactericidal activity (Fig 3a). However, a slight, but significant decrease was observed between the two feeding times in all diet groups. In contrast, decreased levels of NO were observed in Arg1 and Arg2 fish, though only significantly for the lowest supplementation level (Fig 3b). No effect of feeding time was observed on this parameter.
Values represent means ± SEM (n = 6). Asterisks denote differences attributed to feeding time within each diet. Different capital letters stand for statistically significant differences between diets regardless of feeding time (Two-way ANOVA; P < 0.05)
3.5 Gene expression
The relative expression of the 30 studied genes is shown in S1 File: Tables A, B and C (in spleen, AI and PI, respectively). To simplify data interpretation, only differently expressed genes are represented as fold change in Fig 4. Spleen retrieved the highest number of modulated genes, in comparison to both intestinal portions (Fig 4a). Arginase 2 (ARG2) expression was not affected in this tissue by any dietary treatment, but mRNA transcripts of the enzymes glycine amidinotransferase mitochondrial (GATM) and spermine oxidase (SMOX) were up-regulated in Arg1 fish compared to CTRL ones. Interleukin 10 (IL-10), membrane-bound molecules such as C-C chemokine receptor type 3 (CCR3) and myeloid cell surface antigen (CD33) transcripts were up-regulated in Arg1 fish, as well, whereas CCR3 expression level also increased in Arg2 fish compared to CTRL fish. In contrast, S-adenosylmethionine decarboxylase (AMD1), IL-10, interleukin 20 (IL-20) and the atypical chemokine receptor 4 (ACKR4) transcripts decreased in Arg2 fish compared to CTRL diet. When comparing supplementation levels, Arg2 fish showed lower gene expression levels of GATM, SMOX, IL-10, ACKR4 and CD33 than Arg1 fish.
Data are presented as means ± SEM (n = 6). Bars represent fold change of Arg1 (dark grey columns) and Arg2 (light grey columns) relatively to the CTRL group, previously normalized to endogenous β-Actin expression levels. Asterisks indicate significant differences relatively to CTRL group; section sign indicates differences between arginine supplementation levels (One-way ANOVA; P < 0.05)
Dietary treatments did not affect expression of GATM, AMD1, SMOX, IL-20 nor CCR3 in the AI, whereas a decrease in ARG2 transcripts was observed in Arg1 fish compared to CTRL fish (Fig 4b). Furthermore, mRNA expression levels of IL-10, IL-34, ACKR4, T-cell surface glycoprotein CD3 zeta chain (CD247) and CD33 were down-regulated in Arg2 fish. Regarding ACKR4 and CD247, expression patterns were significantly lower than both CTRL and Arg1 fish.
Regarding gene expression patterns of the PI, a significant decrease of ARG2 transcripts was denoted on both dietary groups relatively to the CTRL group, while CD247 gene expression decreased in Arg2 fish (Fig 4c). By contrast, nuclear factor κB (NFKB2) mRNA levels augmented in Arg2 fish. Moreover, the expression levels of CD247 were lower in Arg2 fish, compared to Arg1 specimens.
Discussion
Immunomodulation mediated by arginine has received a special attention in the last years [20–22]. Arginine is an essential AA with versatile functions including protein synthesis, production of urea, synthesis of polyamines, proline and agmatine and it is also involved in endocrine and reproduction regulatory processes [23]. Therefore, its involvement in fish immune response may be essential for managing fish health throughout the full rearing cycle. Thus, it is important to understand the delicate balance of the immune response, in which a complex network of mechanisms is orchestrated by several external and internal factors. Arginine supplementation did not affect fish growth in this study. When juvenile gold pompano (Trachinotus ovatus) were fed six graded levels of arginine for eight weeks, fish growth was firstly increased and then depressed with the highest supplementation levels [24]. The same effect was observed by Zhou et al. [25] in juvenile yellow catfish (Pelteobagrus fulvidraco) fed diets with different levels of arginine for 84 days. The fact that such increase in growth was not observed in the present study may be related to the shorter feeding time (15 and 29 days).
Several studies have considered arginine administration as a strategy that improves the immune response, and, more specifically, the inflammatory process: in fish, previous studies have shown that several factors of the innate immune response, such as the extracellular superoxide anion production, lysozyme activity and neutrophil oxidative radical production were stimulated upon dietary arginine supplementation [26]. In turbot (Scophthalmus maximus), high rearing density caused immunosuppressive effects that were counteracted by dietary arginine supplementation [27]. Furthermore, Chen and co-authors [28] suggested that arginine contributed to an enhanced immune response of Jian carp and higher survival against Aeromonas hydrophila based on the up-regulation of pro-inflammatory gene expression. However, the results of the present study showed an opposite effect of dietary arginine supplementation in European sea bass. Indeed, bacterial challenges with V. anguillarum demonstrated a dose-dependent increased susceptibility of fish fed arginine supplemented diets. Thus, the highest mortalities occurred in the Arg2 groups and the lowest ones in CTRL fish. Mortality after bacterial challenge was also increased in golden pompano (Trachinotus ovatus) when dietary arginine supply was higher than that considered optimum [24]. This is perhaps indicative that arginine surplus might either improve or impair growth, immune response and disease resistance.
In the present study, measurements of gene expression and immune-related factors explained, to a certain extent, the observed higher disease susceptibility. One of the concurrent decreased immune factors in Arg1 and Arg2 fish was the respiratory burst of circulating leucocytes. The respiratory burst of phagocytes is part of the first line of cellular defence mechanisms and involves the production of reactive oxygen intermediates (ROI). This intracellular production of superoxide anion is a well-studied antimicrobial mechanism in fish that can be modulated by several factors [29] and therefore its decrease could be considered an immune-depression component. This is crucial in the current bacterial challenge, as V. anguillarum is able to inhibit leucocyte respiratory burst of European sea bass [30]. Thus, those animals with a reduced ability to produce ROI would be particularly jeopardized as they would display fewer obstacles for this bacterial invasion. The current results are in accordance with those obtained for other fish species, in which extracellular superoxide anion production of head kidney phagocytes was decreased such as in channel catfish (Ictalurus punctatus) fed 2–4% arginine supplemented diets, while no changes were detected in both phagocyte intracellular superoxide anion production and blood neutrophil respiratory burst [31]. By contrast, all respiratory burst values were decreased in fish fed an arginine deficient diet (0.5%). Authors attributed the lower levels of this free radical to a non-activated cells state. However, that would explain superoxide levels similar to the control group, but not lower values. Thus, the fact that, similar to the present work, superoxide anion production was lower indicates an inhibitory effect of arginine. Arginine does not play any direct role in the respiratory burst, and it has been demonstrated that an absence of arginine has no influence on granulocyte functions, including oxidative burst, in murine and human models [32]. However, it was demonstrated in vitro that induction of iNOS increases ROI production in murine macrophages [33]. Thus, the lower levels of plasmatic NO also observed in our study are in accordance with lower ROI production. Another explanation for the lower respiratory burst response could be the involvement of arginine metabolism in myeloid cells [11] which impairs both cell proliferation and activation. As a consequence, the production of superoxide anion would be compromised.
Another decreased immune factor was plasmatic NO, though only significantly in Arg1 fish. At first glance, this might appear contradictory. Since NO is synthesized from L-arginine by the catalytic action of NO synthases (NOS), it would be expected to find higher levels of this molecule when its precursor is more available. However, arginine is also substrate for arginase, which converts L-arginine into L-ornithine and can also be metabolized by the enzyme gatm into creatine. Therefore, supplementing the diet with L-arginine would decrease the competition between the three enzymes by providing extra substrate for them. The transcriptomic results of the genes involved in these metabolic pathways can clarify what occurred in the present study. First of all, a clear down-regulation of ARG2 was detected in the PI of Arg1 and Arg2 fish, and also in the AI of Arg1 fish. ARG2 is an extra-hepatic arginase involved in the production of ornithine, as precursor for polyamines, glutamate and proline, and in the regulation of arginine for NO synthesis [34]. Further, in various teleosts, liver arginase (also named ARG I) activity is induced following several weeks of fasting, as increased arginase activity may be important in AA catabolism in fasting fish [35, 36]. The observed ARG2 down-regulation may have also been affected by a negative feedback set by the increased polyamine turnover. Indeed, SMOX, which is involved in the recycling of spermine (a polyamine) back to spermidine, was up-regulated in the spleen and PI of Arg1 fish, although only significantly in the spleen. Accordingly, AMD1 was equally down-regulated in the spleen of these fish, which supports this hypothesis. The transcription of GATM was also up-regulated in the spleen and AI of Arg1 fish, even though not significantly in the latter tissue. Consequently, an increase in creatine could be expected. Several studies have suggested an anti-inflammatory role of creatinine: in vitro impairment of neutrophil adhesion to human endothelial cells upon creatine supplementation [37]; inhibitory effect on the expression of pathogen receptors in the membrane of human macrophages [38]. Creatine has also been classified as antioxidant [39]. Therefore, a putative increase of creatine biosynthesis would further support our findings regarding the lower plasma NO content, but further studies are needed to corroborate this hypothesis. Concerning the third group of enzymes, NOS, no differences were observed regarding NOSIP transcripts, probably due to the decreased NO production, as this protein promotes de translocation of eNOS (endothelial NOS, a constitutive NOS) from plasma membrane to intracellular sites. Similarly, NOXIN expression was not changed, which is not unexpected, as this gene is strongly induced by different NO donors in mammals. NOXIN plays an anti-apoptotic role, thus when the NOXIN gene is inactivated or down-regulated, cells exhibit higher levels of apoptosis than their counterparts with normal levels of NOXIN [40]. Currently, iNOS of European sea bass is unknown, therefore future studies should address if this inducible form of NOS [41] was indeed unchanged.
In mammalian models, under resting conditions, little arginine is used by myeloid cells and they do not express the major arginine metabolizing enzymes, iNOS and arginase. Thus, dietary arginine supplementation cannot enhance myeloid cell function in the absence of disease. It is only after stimulation that arginine transport into the myeloid cell is greatly increased. Some myeloid cells expressing arginase regulate T-cell function through arginine depletion. In addition, arginase is induced in myeloid cells by T-helper 2 (Th2) cytokines, such as IL-4 and IL-13, and also by IL-6, IL-10, TGF-β, prostaglandins and catecholamines [42]. Further studies are needed to understand all these complex interplaying regulatory factors in fish and how they are modulated after bacterial challenge to better understand the responses obtained before challenge.
The expression profile of immune-related genes differed in fish fed arginine supplemented diets and also supports the higher mortality observed in these groups. In teleosts, spleen is an important haematopoietic organ where melanomacrophages phagocytise and detain blood-borne antigens for a long period of time [43]. This tissue exhibited the highest number of differentially expressed genes, followed by AI and PI. The last portion of fish gut is characterized by a diffused presence of leucocytes in both the lamina propria and the epithelium [44], generally known as the gut-associated lymphoid tissue (GALT). The low modulation of gene expression in the PI may be related to an absence of a stimulatory event, for instance, a bacterial infection, which would certainly lead to immune cells activation. In the present study, pro- and anti-inflammatory interleukins (IL-10, IL-20, IL-34) were in general lower in Arg2 fish, revealing a broad inhibition of the inflammatory response, particularly in the spleen. Only IL-10 was up-regulated in the spleen in Arg1 fish. Furthermore, along with other observed genes, its expression in the spleen of fish given the lowest supplementation was significantly higher than in Arg2 animals. The same pattern was observed in broiler chickens fed arginine-supplemented diets, in which both the expression of IL-1β (pro-inflammatory) and IL-10 (anti-inflammatory) were down-regulated in a dose-dependent manner after a LPS challenge [45]. TGF-β expression, another important anti-inflammatory cytokine in fish, was up-regulated upon infection in Jian carp fed the highest level (24.5 g/kg of diet) of arginine supplementation, which translated in higher disease susceptibility after bacterial challenge [28]. Interleukins are mediators of both mounting and resolution of the inflammatory response [46]. Anti- and pro-inflammatory cytokines are essential for an efficient and correctly assembled inflammation. Anti-inflammatory cytokines are produced as a negative feedback to the secretion of other inflammatory mediators, thereby, avoiding an excessively harmful inflammatory response [47]. Furthermore, expression of arginase and iNOS is reciprocally influenced by Th1 and Th2 cytokines, and therefore activation of each of these cytokines may be restricted to separate subsets of myeloid-derived cells, termed alternative activation [42].
While changes in gene expression of cellular-produced compounds were more evident in the spleen, indicators of immune-related cells presence were more modulated in the AI of individuals fed the arginine diets. Indeed, mRNA levels of cell markers such as ACKR4, CD247 and CD33 dropped substantially in fish fed Arg2, suggesting that arginine was able to depress the cellular immune status of these fish, either by directly affecting cell proliferation or by impairing immune cells differentiation. The expression of NFKB2, a transcriptional factor directly related to the onset of the inflammatory response, was down-regulated in chickens treated with arginine supplementation [45]. By contrast, mRNA levels of NFKB2 were up-regulated in the PI of Arg1 fish. NFKB2 is normally present in the cell and can be rapidly activated either as result of a cascade of events following pathogen receptors activation [48], or by inflammatory mediators such as NO or pro-inflammatory cytokines. In the present context, where no stimulus was present, the up-regulation of this gene cannot be related to the enhancement of the immune response and remains to be clarified.
The inhibitory effect of arginine supplementation was also observed in Jian carp where both in vivo and in vitro arginine supplementations counteracted LPS-induced inflammatory responses [14]. Moreover, this experiment allowed the researchers to associate the inhibitory effects of arginine to a decrease in the expression of the LPS-recognizing receptor, TLR4, and two other molecules downstream of the activated cascade. The same authors suggested this might be a “protective effect” of arginine against LPS-induced inflammation, whereas other authors referred to arginine mode of action as an “alleviation” of the immune challenge caused by Salmonella enterica [49]. However, this issue should be addressed with care at least in fish, since the involvement of arginine in immunity is somehow contradictory. Pro-inflammatory signals and mediators are necessary for the establishment of an efficient immune reaction against a threat; so, their inhibition should not be seen as advantageous for the host. A balanced supplementation should improve the immune response while avoiding the damages of an excessive response.
Conclusions
The present study clearly shows inhibition of some immune mechanisms in the European sea bass as result of dietary arginine supplementation, which led to higher disease susceptibility. These results may be due to the direct role of arginine on cell activation and differentiation leading to a restrained humoral response, or to the action of arginine on cell communications by inhibiting the production of pro-inflammatory mediators. This study provides additional information for deciphering the two-edged effects of a dietary surplus of arginine, as arginine supplementation may produce widely different biological responses depending on the disease process where it is provided. As in human studies [42], we are therefore still in the process of identifying in fish which processes are benefited by arginine-supplemented diets. In fish, the efficiency and balance of the immune system are highly dependent and susceptible to several external and internal varying factors. It is, therefore, of utmost importance to have full knowledge of each specific situation (e.g. developmental stage, fish species, etc.) and conditions (e.g. water temperature, densities, water quality, etc.), while supplementing aquafeeds aiming the improvement of fish health.
Supporting Information
S1 Table. Characteristics of new assembled sequences of European sea bass according to BLAST searches.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0139967.s001
(PDF)
S2 Table. Forward and reverse primers for real-time PCR.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0139967.s002
(PDF)
S1 File. Relative expression of genes involved in the immune response or arginine metabolism in the European sea bass spleen (A), anterior intestine (B) and posterior intestine (C) after 29 days of feeding trial.
Different letters denote significant differences between dietary treatments (One-way ANOVA; P < 0.05)
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0139967.s003
(PDF)
Acknowledgments
Authors thank M.A. González, R. del Pozo and I. Estensoro for excellent assistant in bacterial challenges and gene expression analyses. Authors also thank to M. Machado, for her support during plasma humoral analysis. This publication reflects the views only of the authors, and the European Union cannot be held responsible for any use which may be made of the information contained therein.
Author Contributions
Conceived and designed the experiments: RA JPS ASB BC. Performed the experiments: RA JPS ASB BF. Analyzed the data: RA JPS ASB CA BC. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: JPS ASB BF LT AOT BC. Wrote the paper: RA JPS ASB LT CA AOT BC.
References
- 1. Toranzo AE, Magariños B, Romalde JL. A review of the main bacterial fish diseases in mariculture systems. Aquaculture. 2005;246(1–4):37–61. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.aquaculture.2005.01.002.
- 2. Frans I, Michiels CW, Bossier P, Willems KA, Lievens B, Rediers H. Vibrio anguillarum as a fish pathogen: virulence factors, diagnosis and prevention. J Fish Dis. 2011;34(9):643–61. WOS:000293913000002. pmid:21838709
- 3. Galeottia M, Romano N, Volpatti D, Bulfon C, Brunetti A, Tiscar PG, et al. Innovative vaccination protocol against vibriosis in Dicentrarchus labrax (L.) juveniles: Improvement of immune parameters and protection to challenge. Vaccine. 2013;31(8):1224–30. WOS:000315312500013. pmid:23277096
- 4. Rengpipat S, Rueangruklikhit T, Piyatiratitivorakul S. Evaluations of lactic acid bacteria as probiotics for juvenile seabass Lates calcarifer. Aquac Res. 2008;39(2):134–43. WOS:000252586800003.
- 5. Ringo E, Olsen RE, Gifstad TO, Dalmo RA, Amlund H, Hemre GI, et al. Prebiotics in aquaculture: a review. Aquacult Nutr. 2010;16(2):117–36. WOS:000275725500001.
- 6. Tejera N, Cejas JR, Rodriguez C, Bjerkeng B, Jerez S, Bolanos A, et al. Pigmentation, carotenoids, lipid peroxides and lipid composition of skin of red porgy (Pagrus pagrus) fed diets supplemented with different astaxanthin sources. Aquaculture. 2007;270(1–4):218–30. WOS:000249448300023.
- 7. Buentello JA, Gatlin DM. Effects of elevated dietary arginine on resistance of channel catfish to exposure to Edwardsiella ictaluri. J Aquat Anim Health. 2001;13(3):194–201. WOS:000171382000002.
- 8. Tang L, Wang GX, Jiang J, Feng L, Yang L, Li SH, et al. Effect of methionine on intestinal enzymes activities, microflora and humoral immune of juvenile Jian carp (Cyprinus carpio var. Jian). Aquacult Nutr. 2009;15(5):477–83. WOS:000269537800004.
- 9. Cheng ZY, Gatlin DM, Buentello A. Dietary supplementation of arginine and/or glutamine influences growth performance, immune responses and intestinal morphology of hybrid striped bass (Morone chrysops x Morone saxatilis). Aquaculture. 2012;362:39–43. WOS:000309605000006.
- 10. Li P, Mai KS, Trushenski J, Wu GY. New developments in fish amino acid nutrition: towards functional and environmentally oriented aquafeeds. Amino Acids. 2009;37(1):43–53. WOS:000265685400004. pmid:18751871
- 11. Bronte V, Zanovello P. Regulation of immune responses by L- arginine metabolism. Nat Rev Immunol. 2005;5(8):641–54. WOS:000230880900015. pmid:16056256
- 12. Prolo C, Alvarez MN, Radi R. Peroxynitrite, a potent macrophage- derived oxidizing cytotoxin to combat invading pathogens. Biofactors. 2014;40(2):215–25. WOS:000334690900005. pmid:24281946
- 13. Andersen SM, Holen E, Aksnes A, Ronnestad I, Zerrahn JE, Espe M. Dietary arginine affects energy metabolism through polyamine turnover in juvenile Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar). Brit J Nutr. 2013;110(11):1968–77. WOS:000330345900005. pmid:23656796
- 14. Jiang J, Shi D, Zhou X-Q, Hu Y, Feng L, Liu Y, et al. In vitro and in vivo protective effect of arginine against lipopolysaccharide induced inflammatory response in the intestine of juvenile Jian carp (Cyprinus carpio var. Jian). Fish Shellfish Immun. 2015;42(2):457–64. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.fsi.2014.11.030.
- 15. Kaushik SJ. Whole body amino acid composition of European seabass (Dicentrarchus labrax), gilthead seabream (Sparus aurata) and turbot (Psetta maxima) with an estimation of their IAA requirement profiles. Aquat Living Resour. 1998;11(5):355–8. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0990-7440(98)80007-7.
- 16. Fouz B, Llorens A, Valiente E, Amaro C. A comparative epizootiologic study of the two fish-pathogenic serovars of Vibrio vulnificus biotype 2. J Fish Dis. 2010;33(5):383–90. WOS:000276465300001. pmid:20158583
- 17. Nikoskelainen S, Verho S, Airas K, Lilius EM. Adhesion and ingestion activities of fish phagocytes induced by bacterium Aeromonas salmonicida can be distinguished and directly measured from highly diluted whole blood of fish. Dev Comp Immunol. 2005;29(6):525–37. WOS:000228143700004. pmid:15752549
- 18. Graham S, Jeffries AH, Secombes CJ. A novel assay to detect macrophage bactericidal activity in fish: factors influencing the killing of Aeromonas salmonicida. J Fish Dis. 1988;11(5):389–96. WOS:A1988R164700003.
- 19. Machado M, Azeredo R, Diaz-Rosales P, Afonso A, Peres H, Oliva-Teles A, et al. Dietary tryptophan and methionine as modulators of European seabass (Dicentrarchus labrax) immune status and inflammatory response. Fish Shellfish Immun. 2015;42(2):353–62. pmid:25463296.
- 20. Breuillard C, Cynober L, Moinard C. Citrulline and nitrogen homeostasis: an overview. Amino Acids. 2015;47(4):685–91. WOS:000351383900002. pmid:25676932
- 21. Bogdan C. Nitric oxide synthase in innate and adaptive immunity: an update. Trends Immunol. 2015;36(3):161–78. WOS:000351967000005. pmid:25687683
- 22. Sikalidis AK. Amino acids and immune response: a role for cysteine, glutamine, phenylalanine, tryptophan and arginine in T-cell function and cancer? Pathol Oncol Res. 2015;21(1):9–17. pmid:25351939.
- 23. Li P, Yin YL, Li D, Kim SW, Wu G. Amino acids and immune function. Brit J Nutr. 2007;98(2):237–52. pmid:17403271.
- 24. Lin HZ, Tan XH, Zhou CP, Niu J, Xia DM, Huang Z, et al. Effect of dietary arginine levels on the growth performance, feed utilization, non-specific immune response and disease resistance of juvenile golden pompano Trachinotus ovatus. Aquaculture. 2015;437:382–9. WOS:000348740100051.
- 25. Zhou QC, Jin M, Elmada ZC, Liang XP, Mai KS. Growth, immune response and resistance to Aeromonas hydrophila of juvenile yellow catfish, Pelteobagrus fulvidraco, fed diets with different arginine levels. Aquaculture. 2015;437:84–91. WOS:000348740100011.
- 26. Cheng ZY, Buentello A, Gatlin DM. Effects of dietary arginine and glutamine on growth performance, immune responses and intestinal structure of red drum, Sciaenops ocellatus. Aquaculture. 2011;319(1–2):247–52. WOS:000294751500035.
- 27. Costas B, Rego PCNP, Conceicao LEC, Dias J, Afonso A. Dietary arginine supplementation decreases plasma cortisol levels and modulates immune mechanisms in chronically stressed turbot (Scophthalmus maximus). Aquacult Nutr. 2013;19:25–38. WOS:000326237200002.
- 28. Chen G, Liu Y, Jiang J, Jiang W, Kuang S, Tang L, et al. Effect of dietary arginine on the immune response and gene expression in head kidney and spleen following infection of Jian carp with Aeromonas hydrophila. Fish Shellfish Immun. 2015;44(1):195–202. pmid:25721332.
- 29. Plouffe DA, Hanington PC, Walsh JG, Wilson EC, Belosevic M. Comparison of select innate immune mechanisms of fish and mammals. Xenotransplantation. 2005;12(4):266–77. WOS:000229637300003. pmid:15943775
- 30. Sepulcre MP, Saffopoulou E, Kotoulas G, Meseguer J, Mulero V. Vibrio anguillarum evades the immune response of the bony fish sea bass (Dicentrarchus labrax L.) through the inhibition of leukocyte respiratory burst and down-regulation of apoptotic caspases. Mol Immunol. 2007;44(15):3751–7. WOS:000247822600014. pmid:17485111
- 31. Pohlenz C, Buentello A, Helland SJ, Gatlin DM. Effects of dietary arginine supplementation on growth, protein optimization and innate immune response of channel catfish Ictalurus punctatus (Rafinesque 1818). Aquac Res. 2014;45(3):491–500. WOS:000330630600013.
- 32. Kapp K, Prufer S, Michel CS, Habermeier A, Luckner-Minden C, Giese T, et al. Granulocyte functions are independent of arginine availability. J Leukocyte Biol. 2014;96(6):1047–53. WOS:000344938200012. pmid:25104794
- 33. Zhao K, Huang Z, Lu HL, Zhou JF, Wei TT. Induction of inducible nitric oxide synthase increases the production of reactive oxygen species in RAW264.7 macrophages. Bioscience Rep. 2010;30(4):233–41. WOS:000280628900003.
- 34. Srivastava S, Ratha BK. Unique hepatic cytosolic arginase evolved independently in ureogenic freshwater air-breathing teleost, Heteropneustes fossilis. Plos One. 2013;8(6):e66057. pmid:23840400; PubMed Central PMCID: PMC3688715.
- 35.
Ballantyne JS. Amino acid metabolism. In: WP A., AA J., editors. Nitrogen Excretion. Fish Physiology. 20. 1st ed. San Diego: Academic Press; 2001. p. 77–107.
- 36.
Wood CM. Influence of feeding, exercise and temperature on nitrogen metabolism and excretion. In: Wright PA, Anderson PM, editors. Nitrogen Excretion. 20. 1st ed. San Diego: Academic Press; 2001. p. 201–38.
- 37. Nomura A, Zhang MJ, Sakamoto T, Ishii Y, Morishima Y, Mochizuki M, et al. Anti-inflammatory activity of creatine supplementation in endothelial cells in vitro. Brit J Pharmacol. 2003;139(4):715–20. WOS:000183574500005.
- 38. Leland KM, McDonald TL, Drescher KM. Effect of creatine, creatinine, and creatine ethyl ester on TLR expression in macrophages. Int Immunopharmacol. 2011;11(9):1341–7. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.intimp.2011.04.018. pmid:21575742
- 39. Lawler JM, Barnes WS, Wu G, Song W, Demaree S. Direct antioxidant properties of creatine. Biochem Bioph Res Co. 2002;290(1):47–52. http://dx.doi.org/10.1006/bbrc.2001.6164.
- 40. Nakaya N, Hemish J, Krasnov P, Kim SY, Stasiv Y, Michurina T, et al. noxin, a novel stress-induced gene involved in cell cycle and apoptosis. Mol Cell Biol. 2007;27(15):5430–44. WOS:000248234000015. pmid:17515607
- 41.
Kleinert H, Art J, Pautz A. Regulation of the expression of inducible nitric oxide synthase. In: Ignarro LJ, editor. Nitric Oxide (Second Edition). San Diego: Academic Press; 2010. p. 211–67.
- 42. Popovic PJ, Zeh HJ, Ochoa JB. Arginine and immunity. J Nutr. 2007;137(6):1681s–6s. WOS:000246971500014. pmid:17513447
- 43. Uribe C, Folch H, Enriquez R, Moran G. Innate and adaptive immunity in teleost fish: a review. Vet Med. 2011;56(10):486–503. WOS:000297751900002.
- 44. Rombout JHWM, Abelli L, Picchietti S, Scapigliati G, Kiron V. Teleost intestinal immunology. Fish Shellfish Immun. 2011;31(5):616–26. WOS:000296126100002.
- 45. Tan JZ, Liu SS, Guo YM, Applegate TJ, Eicher SD. Dietary l-arginine supplementation attenuates lipopolysaccharide-induced inflammatory response in broiler chickens. Brit J Nutr. 2014;111(8):1394–404. WOS:000333559700006. pmid:24330949
- 46. Hanada T, Yoshimura A. Regulation of cytokine signaling and inflammation. Cytokine Growth Factor Rev. 2002;13(4–5):413–21. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S1359-6101(02)00026-6. pmid:12220554.
- 47. Ahmed TJ, Kaneva MK, Pitzalis C, Cooper D, Perretti M. Resolution of inflammation: examples of peptidergic players and pathways. Drug Discov Today. 2014;19(8):1166–71. WOS:000341339500018. pmid:24880108
- 48. Lawrence T. The Nuclear Factor NF-κB Pathway in Inflammation. Cold Spring Harbor Perspectives in Biology. 2009;1(6):a001651. PMC2882124. pmid:20457564
- 49. Chen Y, Chen DW, Tian G, He J, Mao XB, Mao Q, et al. Dietary arginine supplementation alleviates immune challenge induced by Salmonella enterica serovar Choleraesuis bacterin potentially through the Toll-like receptor 4-myeloid differentiation factor 88 signalling pathway in weaned piglets. Brit J Nutr. 2012;108(6):1069–76. WOS:000308583400015. pmid:22214652