초록

Korea legislated withdrawing or withholding life-sustaining treatment after the Korean Supreme Court Decision on Grandma Kim’s Case. However, the Proposal for Legislation by the Korean National Bioethics Committee and the Supreme Court decision have some limitations. Both limits the patient’s ability to decide to withdraw or withhold lifesustaining treatment to cases involving a dying patient who is about to die. The Hospice and Life-sustaining Treatment Act also reflected this limitation. Only POLST signed by competent patients themselves is fully respected as a patient’s wishes. The Supreme Court decision reveals theoretical confusion between the principle of respecting autonomy and that of a patient’s best interest. Even though the Proposal and the Act outline certain procedures for surrogate decision-making, they may be problematic in that they place a heavy weight on family members’ decision making. This limitation should be overcome with ethical, legal, and sociological studies. Despites this limitation, any legislation based on the Proposal was needed in Korea. Building a medical system with better palliative care or hospice care should be emphasized to prevent the abuse of withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment. The values of familism should be balanced with those of autonomy.

키워드

life-sustaining Treatment, Grandma Kim’s Case, Living Will, POLST, Surrogate Decision-making

참고문헌(9)open

  1. [단행본] Beauchamp, Tom L / 2009 / Principles of Biomedical Ethics / Oxford University Press

  2. [단행본] Beauchamp, Tom L / 2013 / Principles of Biomedical Ethics / Oxford University Press

  3. [학술지] 최지윤 / 2009 / 무의미한 연명치료중단에 대한 환자의 자기 결정권 -대법원 2009.5.21 선고 2009다17417등을 중심으로 / 생명윤리정책연구 3 (2) : 155 ~ 172

  4. [학술지] 최경석 / 2014 / 김 할머니 사건에 대한 대법원 판결의 논거 분석과 비판: “자기결정권 존중”과“최선의 이익”충돌 문제를 중심으로 / 생명윤리정책연구 8 (2) : 227 ~ 251

  5. [단행본] Choi, Kyungsuk / 2015 / Family-Oriented Informed Consent: East Asian and American Perspectives / Springer : 83 ~ 91

  6. [단행본] Dolgin, Janet L / 2009 / Bioethics and the Law / Wolters Kluwer

  7. [학술지] Hardwig, J / 1997 / Is There a Duty to Die? / Hastings Center Report 27 (2) : 34 ~ 42

  8. [학술지] Hardwig, J / 1990 / What About the Family? / Hastings Center Report 20 (2) : 5 ~ 10

  9. [학술지] 권복규 / 2010 / 우리나라 일부 병원에서 환자, 보호자, 의료진의 연명치료 중지 관련 의사결정에 관한 태도 / 한국의료윤리학회지 13 (1) : 1 ~ 16