Skip to main navigation menu Skip to main content Skip to site footer
##common.pageHeaderLogo.altText##

Original article

Vol. 141 No. 4546 (2011)

Prison medicine, public health policy and ethics: the Geneva experience

  • Bernice S. Elger
DOI
https://doi.org/10.4414/smw.2011.13273
Cite this as:
Swiss Med Wkly. 2011;141:w13273
Published
07.11.2011

Summary

The health care of prisoners represents a public health priority. However, in many countries, the pursuit of public health goals in prison is not granted. Introducing condom distribution and syringe exchange in prisons remains the exception.

This article describes the example of a Swiss canton in which the legal framework enables health-care personnel to put into practice health care that is equivalent to the care available to non imprisoned persons including harm reduction measures for prisoners. The article describes the medical institutions in charge of health care for prisoners and the legal and ethical framework, its repercussions on the clinical and public health context, as well as persisting difficulties.

The Geneva experience shows that in spite of the legal context, preventive measures, free informed consent and confidentiality have to be constantly defended by physicians and public health authorities. Both need to be regularly educated on their obligations towards prisoner patients. A complaint mechanism granted to detainees as part of the legal framework is important to adapt existing practice to new challenges.

References

  1. Jurgens R, Ball A, Verster A. Interventions to reduce HIV transmission related to injecting drug use in prison. Lancet Infect Dis. 2009;9:57–66.
  2. Small W, Kain S, Laliberte N, Schechter MT, O'Shaughnessy MV, Spittal PM. Incarceration, addiction and harm reduction: Inmates experience injecting drugs in prison. Subst Use Misuse. 2005;40:831–43.
  3. Arroyo-Cobo JM. Public health gains from health in prisons in Spain. Public Health. 2010;124:629–31.
  4. WHO, UNODC, UNAIDS: Interventions to address HIV in prisons: Effectiveness of interventions to address hiv in prisons. Evidence for action technical paper: http://www.Who.Int/hiv/topics/idu/prisons/en/index.Html. Geneva, World Health Organization, 2007.
  5. COE: Council of Europe (COE) committee of ministers Rec(1998)7 on the ethical and organisational aspects of health care in prison: www.Coe.Int/t/e/legal_affairs/legal_co-operation/prisons_and_alternatives/legal_instruments/ rec.R(98)7%20.Asp http://www.Coe.Int/t/e/legal_affairs/legal_co-operation/prisons_and_alternatives/legal_instruments/ rec.R(98)7.Asp, accessed September 2007.
  6. UN: United Nations (UN). Basic principles for the treatment of prisoners. Adopted and proclaimed by general assembly resolution 45/111 of 14 December 1990: http://www.Unhchr.Ch/html/menu3/b/h_comp35.Htm, accessed September 2007, art. 9.
  7. Jurgens R, Csete J, Amon JJ, Baral S, Beyrer C. People who use drugs, HIV, and human rights. Lancet. 2010;376:475–85.
  8. Seim L. Europe: Court finds lack of medical assistance in russian detention facility to be in violation of human rights. HIV AIDS Policy Law Rev. 2007;12:49.
  9. Lines R. Using human rights law to advocate for syringe exchange programs in european prisons. HIV AIDS Policy Law Rev. 2006;11:80–2.
  10. Welsh J: La médecine en milieu pénitentiaire et les droits de l’homme in Bertrand D, Niveau, G. (ed Médecine, santé et prison Geneva, Editions Médecine et Hygiène, 2006, p 113–24.
  11. Jürgens R, Cook C, Lines R. Out of sight, out of mind? Harm reduction in prisons and other places of detention; in Cook C (ed The global state of harm reduction. London, International Harm Reduction Association, 2010.
  12. Jacob J, Stover H. The transfer of harm-reduction strategies into prisons: Needle exchange programmes in two german prisons. Int J Drug Policy. 2000;11:325–35.
  13. Tucker JD, Chang SW, Tulsky JP. The catch 22 of condoms in us correctional facilities. BMC Public Health. 2007;7:296.
  14. Sylla M, Harawa N, Grinstead Reznick O. The first condom machine in a us jail: The challenge of harm reduction in a law and order environment. Am J Public Health;100:982–5.
  15. Hayton P, van den Bergh B, Moller L. Health protection in prisons: The madrid recommendation. Public Health. 2010;124:635–6.
  16. K155.04: Articles 1, 2, 3, 11, 12 of the “règlement de l’institut universitaire de médecine légale”.
  17. F150.16: “règlement du quartier carcéral psychiatrique” May 4, 1988,
  18. F150.20: “règlement du centre de sociothérapie «la pâquerette»” July 27, 1988,
  19. F150.04: Articles 29 and 30 of the “règlement sur le régime intérieur de la prison et le statut des personnes incarcérées”. September 30, 1985
  20. State-Council: Arrêté du conseil de l’etat (entrée en vigueur le 27.9.2000). Documents des hug. Santé et soins en milieu carcérale. Référence aml/2.4.4 publié le 12.4.2005. 2000
  21. K103: Loi sur la santé du 7 avril 2006.
  22. Elger BS. Does insomnia in prison improve with time? Prospective study among remanded prisoners using the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index. Med Sci Law. 2003;43:334–44.
  23. Elger BS. Prevalence, types and possible causes of insomnia in a swiss remand prison. Eur J Epidemiol. 2004;19:665–77.
  24. Elger BS, Bindschedler M, Goehring C, Revaz SA. Evaluation of drug prescription at the Geneva prison’s outpatient service in comparison to an urban outpatient medical service. Pharmacoepidemiol Drug Saf. 2004;13:633–44.
  25. Elger BS, Goehring C, Revaz SA, Morabia A. Prescription of hypnotics and tranquilisers at the Geneva prison’s outpatient service in comparison to an urban outpatient medical service. Soz Praventivmed. 2002;47:39–43.
  26. Bungnon G. Le constat médical peut-il mettre à l’épreuve les frontières de la force policière légitime? Enquête sur un dispositif médico-légal de dépistage des violences policières. Déviance et Société. 2011;35:113–36.
  27. Dolan KA, Wodak A. HIV transmission in a prison system in an Australian state. Med J Aust. 1999;171:14–7.
  28. Betteridge G. U.S.: Evidence of HIV transmission in prisons. HIV AIDS Policy Law Rev. 2006;11:37–9.
  29. Nelles J, Harding T. Preventing HIV transmission in prison: A tale of medical disobedience and swiss pragmatism. Lancet. 1995;346:1507–8.
  30. Elger BS, Spaulding A. Research on prisoners – a comparison between the IOM committee recommendations (2006) and European regulations. Bioethics. 2010;24:1–13.
  31. Goldberg D, Taylor A, McGregor J, Davis B, Wrench J, Gruer L. A lasting public health response to an outbreak of HIV infection in a Scottish prison? Int J STD AIDS 1998;9:25–30.
  32. Harding T, Zimmermann E. Psychiatric symptoms, cognitive stress and vulnerability factors. A study in a remand prison. Br J Psychiatry. 1989;155:36–43.
  33. Jeanmonod R, Harding T, Staub C. Treatment of opiate withdrawal on entry to prison. Br J Addict. 1991;86:457–63.
  34. Schaller G, Harding T. information on health risks in prisons: Evaluation of a leaflet. Soz Praventivmed. 1996;41:288–94.
  35. Zega L. Etude sur les décès à la prison genevoise de Champ-Dollon 1977–1992. Genève, Faculté de Médecine, doctoral thesis no. 9743, 1996.
  36. Neeser M, Ruedin P, Restellini JP: “Thirst strike”: Hypernatraemia and acute prerenal failure in a prisoner who refused to drink. BMJ. 1992;304:1352.
  37. Beauverd Y, Poletti PA, Wolff H, Ris F, Dumonceau JM, Elger BS. A body-packer with a cocaine bag stuck in the stomach. World journal of radiology. 2011;3:155-8.
  38. Elger BS. Management and evolution of insomnia complaints among non-substance-misusers in a swiss remand prison. Swiss Med Wkly. 2004;134:486–99.
  39. Elger BS. Prison life: Television, sports, work, stress and insomnia in a remand prison. Int J Law Psychiatry. 2009;32:74–83.
  40. Eytan A, Haller DM, Wolff H, Cerutti B, Sebo P, Bertrand D, et al. Psychiatric symptoms, psychological distress and somatic comorbidity among remand prisoners in Switzerland. International journal of law and psychiatry. 2011;34:13-9.
  41. Wolff H, Sebo P, Haller DM, Eytan A, Niveau G, Bertrand D, et al. Health problems among detainees in Switzerland: a study using the ICPC-2 classification. BMC public health. 2011;11:245.
  42. Niveau G, Ritter C. Route of administration of illicit drugs among remand prison entrants. Eur Addict Res. 2008;14:92–8.
  43. Steiner AS, Haller DM, Elger BS, Sebo P, Gaspoz JM, Wolff H. Chlamydia trachomatis infection in a swiss prison: A cross sectional study. Swiss Med Wkly. 2010;140:w13126.
  44. Haller DM, Steiner AS, Sebo P, Gaspoz JM, Wolff H. Chlamydia trachomatis infection in males in a juvenile detention facility in Switzerland. Swiss Med Wkly. 2011;141:w13220.
  45. Getaz L, Rieder JP, Siegrist CA, Kramer MC, Stoll B, Humair JP, et al. Improvement of measles immunity among migrant populations: lessons learned from a prevalence study in a Swiss prison. Swiss Med Wkly. 2011;141:w13215.
  46. Bernath B, Restellini J-P, Robert C-N. Avis d’experts mandatés par le bureau du grand conseil concernant la pétition des détenus de champ-dollon de mars 2006: http://www.Humanrights.Ch/home/upload/pdf/070418_experts_rapport_champ-dollon.Pdf, accessed September 2007.
  47. COE: Council of Europe (COE 2006a). Recommendation Rec(2006)2 of the committee of ministers to member states on the European prison rules (adopted by the committee of ministers on 11 january 2006 at the 952nd meeting of the ministers’ deputies): Https://wcd.Coe.Int/viewdoc.Jsp?Id=955747, accessed September 2007.
  48. SAMS: Swiss academy of medical sciences (2002): The exercise of medical activities in respect of detained persons: http://www.Samw.Ch/en/ethics/guidelines/currently-valid-guidelines.Html (accessed January 5, 2011), 2002,
  49. France: Ministère de la justice (France), ministère de l’emploi et de la solidarité, inspection générale des services judiciaires, inspection générale des affaires sociales. Rapport d’évaluation à madame la ministre de l’emploi et de la solidarité, à madame la garde des sceaux, ministre de la justice, et à monsieur le ministre délégué à la santé. Juin 2001. Code igas 2001054; code igsj 200106 : http://www.Ladocumentationfrancaise.Fr/rapports-publics/024000176/index.Shtml, accessed September 2007.
  50. Gastone R. Medical-social study of women incarcerated in the fleury-merogis prison in 2000 and 2001. Sante Publique. 2003;15:133–59.